And then someone found the case in Rosa's room. I do not remember who found it. I remember the silence that fell when it was carried downstairs and set on the hall table. It was the velvet case, the same case, and it was empty. Victoria looked at it, and then she looked at Rosa, who was standing at the foot of the stairs with her hands folded in front of her, and she said, in a voice so cold it frightened me, that there it was. There was the proof. Rosa had taken the necklace and hidden the case in her room.
Rosa went pale. She said she had not taken anything. She said it quietly, the way she said everything, and nobody listened. Victoria was already shouting. She said Rosa had been in the bedroom that morning. She said Rosa was the only one who cleaned the rooms. She said the case did not walk itself into Rosa's room. She said Rosa must have taken the necklace and sold it, or hidden it somewhere, and that the case was all that was left of it.
I stood there and I watched it happen, and I did not stop it. I did not ask Rosa a single question. I did not ask Victoria how she knew. I looked at the empty case on the table, and I looked at Rosa's face, and I thought about how neatly it all fitted together, and I let it fit. That is the truth of that morning. The necklace was gone. The case was in Rosa's room. My wife was certain. And I was a coward.
The search went on for hours. We opened drawers that had not been opened in years. We looked under beds and behind curtains and inside the linen cupboard. Victoria directed it all, standing in the hall with her arms folded, telling us where to look, telling us what to look for, telling us that the necklace had to be somewhere in the house because no one had left the house since the night before. She was very calm by then, very certain, and her certainty filled the house the way smoke fills a room. The cook was sent to search the kitchen. The gardener was sent to search the shed. I was sent to search the study, though I did not know what I was looking for. And all the while Rosa stood at the foot of the stairs, with her hands folded in front of her, saying nothing, watching us tear the house apart looking for something she had not taken. I think about that morning now, and I think about how strange it was, how we searched everywhere except the one place the truth was hiding, which was in plain sight, in my wife's own handbag, in the receipt she had folded small and tucked away.
By noon, the whole house believed Rosa had stolen it. The cook believed it. The gardener believed it. I believed it. The only person in that house who did not believe it, I learned much later, was my mother, who had been standing in the doorway of her room the whole time, watching, with those eyes of hers, saying nothing at all.
Victoria dismissed Rosa that same night. She did not wait for the morning. She did not wait for anyone to think. She stood in the hall, in her evening dress, with her hair still pinned up from the day, and she told Rosa to pack her bag and go. She said she would not have a thief in her house. She said Rosa had one hour. She said if Rosa was not gone by then, she would call the police.
Rosa did not argue. She stood very still, with her hands folded in front of her, and she looked at Victoria, and then she looked at me, and I saw something in her face that I have never forgotten. It was not anger. It was not fear. It was disappointment, the quiet kind, the kind that comes when a person realises that the people she trusted are not who she thought they were. She said, very quietly, that she had not taken the necklace. She said she had never stolen anything in her life. She said she loved this house, and she loved Lucas, and she would never have done such a thing. Victoria told her to save her lies for someone who believed them.
I stood between them, and I did nothing. I want to be honest about that, because it is the worst thing I did in all of this, and I have had five years to look at it. I did not ask Rosa to stay. I did not ask Victoria to wait. I did not say, let us think about this, let us be sure. I believed my wife. It was easier to believe her than to doubt her. It was easier to believe that Rosa had stolen the necklace than to believe that the woman I had married was capable of lying to my face in my own hall. So I stood there, and I let my wife throw out the woman who had raised my son, and I told myself that justice had been done.