She saw more than anyone knew. She saw that Victoria was cold to Lucas, and that Rosa was warm to him, and that the boy had already made his choice long before anyone asked him to. She saw that Victoria resented Rosa for it, the way a woman resents the person who does the thing she cannot do herself. She saw the way Victoria's eyes followed Rosa around the house, not with gratitude but with something harder, something closer to hate. And she saw the necklace. She saw how Victoria wore it to every party, how she touched it when she was nervous, how she kept it in her own drawer and never let anyone else near it.
My mother loved Rosa. They talked in the kitchen in the afternoons, when the house was quiet, and Catherine would ask Rosa about her day, and Rosa would tell her, and they would laugh together in a way that Victoria never laughed with anyone in that house. My mother loved Lucas, too. He would climb onto her lap, small as he was, and she would tell him stories, and he would fall asleep against her shoulder with his thumb in his mouth. She was the one person in that house, besides Rosa, who loved that boy without wanting anything back from him.
In the afternoons, when the house was quiet, my mother and Rosa would sit in the kitchen together, and my mother would ask her about her day, and Rosa would tell her, and they would talk the way two women talk when they trust each other. My mother asked her once, I learned later, whether Victoria was kind to her, and Rosa said that Victoria was the mistress of the house and that it was not her place to judge. My mother said that kindness was not a matter of place, and that a woman who was unkind to the people who served her would one day be unkind to everyone. Rosa said nothing to that. She simply poured my mother another cup of tea, and they sat together in the quiet kitchen, and neither of them said what they were both thinking. My mother knew. She knew Victoria the way a mother knows the woman her son has married, with all her faults laid bare, and she knew Rosa the way a woman knows another woman who has been wronged and has borne it in silence.
She was watching, and she was keeping count. I did not understand that until much later. I thought she was simply an old woman sitting in a chair. I did not know she was gathering the truth, piece by piece, the way a woman gathers firewood before a storm. She knew something was coming. She knew Victoria. And she knew, I think, that one day someone would have to speak for Rosa, because no one else in that house was going to.
The necklace was a Harrington heirloom. It had belonged to my grandmother, and my mother had given it to Victoria on our wedding day, in a velvet case, with her own hands. Diamonds, set in a plain gold chain, nothing showy about it except the stones themselves, which caught the light like cold water. Victoria wore it to every party that mattered. She touched it when she was nervous, the way other women touch a wedding ring. It was the finest thing she owned, and she knew it, and she made sure everyone else knew it too.
It went missing five years ago, on an ordinary morning in the spring. I remember the morning because it began like any other, and by noon nothing in the house was the same. Victoria came downstairs in her dressing gown, her face white, and said the necklace was gone. Her drawer was open. The velvet case was there, but the necklace was not in it. She said it as if she were reporting a death. Someone had taken it. Someone in this house had taken it.
We searched. That is what I remember most clearly about that morning, the searching. We opened every drawer in the bedroom. We looked behind the dressing table and under the bed. We went through the wardrobe and the linen cupboard and the drawers in the hall. Victoria stood in the middle of it all, directing us, her voice rising with every empty drawer. She said the necklace had been there the night before. She said she had put it away herself. She said no one had been in the bedroom except the family and the staff.