"If You Allow, I Can Play" — Homeless Black Woman Sat at Billionaire's Piano, Silenced 200 Guests

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

They chose it together in the end, arguing happily over the Schubert's placement like generals over a map, and when the program lay written out fair — Bach, Chopin, Schubert, and last, where Etta had already placed it in her heart, the Liszt — Naomi read it through and said, "You end with the Liebesträume," and Etta said, "I end with the Liebesträume," and neither of them said anything more about it, because musicians know that some sentences are chords: you don't explain them, you play them.

He came to the station on a Tuesday, in the rain, without an umbrella.

Etta saw him before he saw her — saw the cut of the coat first, wrong for the weather and wrong for the concourse, a man tailored for rooms with carpets standing in the one cathedral in the city that belonged to everybody. No Vanessa. No phone in his hand. His hair was wet at the edges and his expensive shoes were dark with rain, and he stood at the top of the stairs doing what she had watched Grant do: searching the river for one face.

She let him search a moment longer than kindness required. Then she played the opening of the nocturne, and his head came around the way a man's head comes around at his own name.

He did not approach the piano directly. He bought a coffee he did not drink from the cart, and he stood with it at the proper distance, and he listened to the whole piece and the one after it, while the morning river flowed around them both, and only when she closed the lid for the nine o'clock lull did he come and stand — not sit, stand, like a student called forward — at the end of the piano.

I rehearsed this in the car, he said. "Which I drove myself, you'll notice. That was going to be my first point. I've decided not to make it."

Prudent, Etta said.

I had a statement. Vanessa wrote the bones of it before I — before. He turned the coffee cup in his hands. "It used the word 'journey' four times. I have instructed her to kill the discovery campaign, Mrs. Lawson. All of it. The sequel gala, the documentary, the licensing. It's done. The video — the gala video — the revenue it has made and will make is being transferred to you. Not the foundation. You. My lawyer used the phrase 'your property, belatedly returned.' I liked the phrase. It was the first honest one in the file."

Etta considered him with the level attention she had once given juries.

Why? she asked.

Trent laughed — one short, unpracticed sound. "Because my father sat in a music room with me for three hours last week and told me about my mother, and at the end of it I understood that I have spent ten years turning the worst thing that ever happened to our family into an annual event with a sponsorship deck. And because you — " He stopped, and started over, badly, which she could see cost him more than fluency would have. "You asked permission to sit at that piano. Five words. If you allow. You were a dishwasher in a house where I was the host, and you asked, and I said yes the way you'd let a dog do a trick. And then you played my mother's music like you'd been keeping it safe for her. I've had eleven years and all the money there is, and I never once sat down and did the thing you did in your work clothes with wet hands."

I watched the video forty-six times the night of the gala, Trent said. "Vanessa showed me the counter. I kept watching the part where you wash your hands first. A woman about to be humiliated in front of my guests, and she stops to wash her hands like a surgeon, like the piano deserved clean hands. I couldn't stand it and I couldn't stop watching it. That's what a conscience is, I think. Something you can't stop watching." He shrugged inside the wet coat, a young man's gesture, unguarded. "I don't have a second act planned, Mrs. Lawson. That's the whole confession. I just have the first one, and I'm trying to stop charging admission to it."

The announcements rolled over them. A train sighed somewhere below.

My mother had a phrase for apologies, Etta said at last. "She said an apology is a debt paid in the right currency or it's just noise in the room. You're paying in the right currency, Mr. Ellison. Slowly. Keep going."

Trent, he said.

Mr. Ellison, she said, without cruelty, "we are not there. But we are somewhere." She flexed her hands once, absently, and he watched it as if it were a speech. "You killed the campaign?"

Today. And I told the board why, in full sentences, with my name on them.

And the video money — I don't want a sum I can't understand. Have your lawyer send it through Mrs. Adeyemi's office, with the arithmetic shown. I'll read it twice. Then I'll decide what it's for.

Done. He hesitated at the edge of the one thing he had actually come for, and she watched a man raised to acquire things discover he did not know how to ask for one. "The recital. At Ashford. The dean isn't announcing it, but the building knows, and the building talks." He set the untouched coffee down on the piano and caught himself and picked it up again, flustered, human. "May I — I'd like to attend. Not the gala version. Just — attend. If you allow."

Etta looked at him for a long moment, and something in her face — not softness, exactly; fairness — settled.

Buy a ticket like everyone else, she said.

News in the same category

"If You Allow, I Can Play" — Homeless Black Woman Sat at Billionaire's Piano, Silenced 200 Guests

30 Part