"If You Allow, I Can Play" — Homeless Black Woman Sat at Billionaire's Piano, Silenced 200 Guests

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Clean. That was the first thing, and she registered it with a professional's distant pleasure: the attack clean, the tone placed exactly where she intended it, the sound rising into the high dark of the hall and coming back to her warmed. There was no tentativeness in it and no showing off; there was a woman of fifty-eight playing the way she had been formed to play before she was old enough to drive, the phrases thought whole before they were sounded, the silences between them measured like speech. Down in the third row she could not see Mrs. Adeyemi nod, but she knew the nod was happening. Around her, eight hundred people performed the small miracle she had stopped believing an audience could perform: they settled, entirely, and trusted her.

The program had begun, and it was hers — every tempo, every pause, every breath of it, hers.

She played the first half of the program the way a river takes its banks: without argument, carrying everything. Applause came and went between the pieces like weather she was grateful for and did not mistake for the journey. She rose once, bowed once, sat again. Her hands were warm now, fully awake, and the small animal fear that had ridden in her chest since morning had curled somewhere below the music and gone quiet.

Then came the piece from James's last birthday.

It sat in the middle of the program where she had put it deliberately, the way you place a chair for a guest you are expecting. Twenty years of birthdays had had other music; the last one — three years and two months ago — had had this. The apartment had still been theirs then, though the illness was already in the walls like damp. James was thinner that year, careful with stairs, furious at being careful. There had been a cake from the bakery on the corner because she had refused to let him know she'd stopped trusting her own baking under the pressure of the day, and candles she could count on one hand because fifty-five candles, he'd said, would constitute a fire hazard and a metaphor. He had sat in the good chair with his hands folded over the blanket she pretended was for decoration. Play the one I like, he'd said. You know the one.

He had not been able to sing that year — the breath wasn't there — so he had hummed the first bars instead, badly, the way he had hummed everything for thirty years, in the cracks between the notes. She had corrected him for thirty years. She would have given anything she had left to be corrected by that humming now.

She had played it at the upright with the E that stuck in wet weather. It had not stuck that day.

Now, in the hall, she came to the place in the piece where the melody turns — turns the way a man turns in a doorway to look back at a room he loves — and the memory did not arrive as a picture. It arrived as sound: James's breathing, the slight whistle the illness had put in it that winter, keeping time under the music from the good chair. She could hear it more clearly than the piano. Her hands, which had not consulted her about anything all evening, consulted the memory instead. They slowed. They gentled. Mid-phrase, in the middle of the turn, they stopped.

The silence that fell was total, and it went on.

Five seconds. Ten. The hall did not rustle. Eight hundred people, and not one program slid, not one throat was cleared, not one phone — that modern cough — lit up in the dark. Later, none of them would be able to say how long it lasted; the ushers would disagree by minutes. What Etta knew, sitting in it with her hands hovering and her heart going like a fist on a door, was that the silence was not empty and it was not impatient. The terrace at Bryn Mawr had watched her to see what she would do. This room was doing something else. This room was holding still with her, the way you hold still beside a hospital bed, the way you do not reach for a grieving person's hand until they reach first. They were not waiting for her to fail. They were not even waiting, exactly. They were accompanying her, in the only register she had left them.

She breathed. It was the first fully conscious breath she had taken since she sat down, and it reached all the way to the bottom of her.

She looked up, once, at the hall — the dim sea of faces, the front row where Grant Ellison sat with his head slightly bowed, not watching her grief but attending it — and she thought of the station piano, and the commuters who had streamed past her for two years without ever knowing her name, and how some of them, a few, had slowed. Had stopped, in fact. Had stood with their transfers in their hands and listened to the end of a phrase before the train took them. Somebody was always listening. That had been true on the platform. It was true in this hall. It had been true, she understood suddenly, on the terrace too, and in the apartment, and in the good chair, where a dying man had listened to this very piece as if it were a letter being read aloud.

She lifted her hands and began the phrase again, from its beginning.

She played it the way you say a name the second time, correctly — not louder, not sadder, truer. The turn came, and she took it the way he would have taken it: without flinching from the look back. The rest of the piece unfolded under her hands deeper than she had ever played it, even in the apartment, even in the years when she performed it for juries and students and said all the correct technical things about it. She had always known how the piece went. She had not always known what it was for.

News in the same category

"If You Allow, I Can Play" — Homeless Black Woman Sat at Billionaire's Piano, Silenced 200 Guests

30 Part