"If You Allow, I Can Play" — Homeless Black Woman Sat at Billionaire's Piano, Silenced 200 Guests

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Mrs. Lawson. She shook Etta's hand in the shelter's little visiting room as if they were closing something. "I'm Vanessa Crane. I handle communications for the Ellison family. Let me say first: what you did Saturday night was the most beautiful thing I've ever seen at one of our events, and I've seen a proposal at the opera. I cried. Our whole office cried."

Then your office has good taste, Etta said, "and a water bill."

Vanessa laughed exactly the right amount. "Can I be direct? That video is at forty million views. Forty. The world has decided you are its story this week, and the world is a machine, Mrs. Lawson — it will tell your story with you or without you, and without you it will tell it wrong. Missing teeth wrong. Cardboard sign wrong. I have seen what they do to women like—" She caught herself, recalibrated, smiled. "To stories like yours. I can protect you. That's what I'm offering."

Protect me, Etta repeated.

And pay you. Let me show you.

The folio opened like a menu. There was a phrase for what she was — Vanessa used it twice, proudly, the way she'd coined it: the gala's Cinderella. There was a plan: the exclusive interview, one network, prime time; the follow-up magazine profile with photographs (a stylist, a dress, "nothing costume-y, we respect the authenticity"); the morning-show circuit; the charity single — a recording, actually, properly produced, her playing, proceeds split. There was a media coach. There was a schedule already printed, in a font that brooked no argument, running six weeks. Six weeks, itemized like the stations of something: day three, the stylist; day nine, the exclusive; day twenty-two, the photographs, location to be determined, "somewhere with texture." Etta found her own name on that schedule eleven times and her own preferences nowhere — not even in pencil, not even as a courtesy.

And there was the contract. Exclusive life-story rights, all media, in perpetuity, with approval over her portrayal resting — Etta read it twice, slowly, the way she had once read publishers' contracts for her students — with the company. A fee: seventy-five thousand dollars, a number chosen, she understood at once, to be life-changing to a woman in a shelter and rounding error to the people offering it. Payable in installments tied to appearances. Her obligations listed for two pages. Their obligations listed for one paragraph, and that paragraph had the word endeavor in it, which Etta had taught her students was Latin for we'll see.

Mrs. Crane, she said at last. "May I ask who wrote this?"

Our counsel, with my team.

Your counsel writes like a man who's never missed a meal. She laid the contract flat and put her palm on it, gently, the way you settle a restless page of music. "I have played the piano for fifty years. I have been homeless for two. In your contract, the fifty years are worth seventy-five thousand dollars, and the two years are worth" — she turned a page — "my name, my face, my husband's illness, my eviction, and the right to tell it all again whenever the ratings require a warm feeling. Forever. I find the proportions interesting."

Vanessa's smile had become professional, which was to say it had stopped pretending to be warm. "The fee is negotiable within a range."

I'm sure it is. Everything in this room is negotiable except the part that matters. Etta folded her hands. The visiting room had a cross on the wall and a clock that lost time, and through the door came the smell of the kitchen's soup. "Miss Crane. When the six weeks are over — when the story is told, and the single is released, and the world moves on to the next warm feeling — where do I live?"

The fee—

The fee is money. Money ends; that's its nature; I have had money and I have buried it with my husband. I'm asking about the part after. The exclusive rights are forever, it says so here, in perpetuity. The makeover, the schedule, the coach — six weeks. And then the story is over and the rights remain yours and I remain— She gestured, not at the room, but at the fact of the room. "Here. Or somewhere like here, with better stories to tell the intake worker. You are offering to buy my life at the exact moment it is most valuable and sell it back to me as a memory."

For the first time since she'd arrived, Vanessa Crane was silent. It wasn't a defeated silence; Etta could see the machinery working behind her eyes, searching the day's inventory for the counterargument, and failing to find one that wasn't an insult.

You've had offers before, Vanessa said finally. "Haven't you."

I had a career before, Etta said. "Contracts are contracts, Miss Crane. The ink doesn't care who holds the pen." She slid the folio back across the little table, squared it with the table's edge out of a tidiness older than anything in the room. "Tell Mr. Ellison — the younger one — that I thank him for the offer. Tell him the story is not for sale, because the story is not finished. And tell him that if his family wants to help me, the help they're offering has my whole life in it, and I am still living it."

People kept asking her how it had happened, as if there must have been a single stair she had missed — a fire, a fraud, a villain — and Etta understood the wish. A single stair can be repaired. What had happened to Etta Lawson was not a stair. It was arithmetic.

Begin here: for twenty-two years, she taught piano at the Ashford Conservatory in Philadelphia, rising from the adjunct scramble to a full professorship with her name on the faculty recital programs, a studio of students who feared her standards and adored her in the precise proportions she intended. She played the faculty series. She played chamber music on Sundays. In 1998 she recorded an album of nocturnes that sold modestly and was reviewed, in one magazine that mattered, with the phrase like light through a curtain, which James had cut out and kept in his wallet until the wallet wore out.

News in the same category

"If You Allow, I Can Play" — Homeless Black Woman Sat at Billionaire's Piano, Silenced 200 Guests

30 Part