she watched the snow fall, and she watched the twins play, and she was glad, and she was sad, and she was glad and sad at the same time, and that was the way it was, and that was the way it would be. She thought about the night she had lain awake, a week ago, and listened to the twins calling Charity "Mama" through the wall, and about how the word had hurt her, and about how she had not known what to do, and about how Patience had said to her, the next morning, in the kitchen, very plainly, "They call her Mama because she is the one who is with them all day. It is not a judgment. It is a habit," and about how those words had stayed with her, and about how she had gone to Charity, and how she had said, very quietly, "Please don't let them call you Mama. I am their mother," and about how Charity had agreed at once, and how she had said, gently, to the twins, "I am not your Mama. Your Mama is Constance," and about how the twins had been sad, and about how Patience had said to her, "Let them choose a word of their own for her," and about how she had asked them, and about how they had chosen Cherry, and about how the choosing had changed everything, and about how it had changed nothing, and about how the word had come home to her, not because she had taken it back, but because it had been given back, and because it had never truly left, and because a word that belonged to a mother could not be taken, not by a child, and not by anyone, and she knew that now, and she would not forget it again.
At midday, when the twins came in from the snow with their cheeks red and their mittens wet, Constance helped Charity dry them, and they sat by the fire, and Constance mended the twins' dresses, and Charity read to the twins from the book of stories, and her voice was low and steady, and the twins listened, and Constance listened too, and the fire crackled, and the kettle sang, and the house was warm, and the snow fell outside, slow and steady, and it was a good afternoon, the kind of afternoon that made a house feel like a house, and Constance thought about the drawing pinned to the wall above Charity's bed, the drawing of the house with everyone in it, and she thought about how the drawing had a place for everyone, and how that was right, and how the house had a place for everyone, and how that was right too, and she went on with her mending, and the afternoon went on, slow and golden, even in the snow. Then Alice said, "Mama, will you read to us now? Cherry read to us, and now it is your turn," and Emma said, "Yes, Mama, read the one about the river, the way Cherry reads it," and Constance set her mending aside, and she took the book of stories, and she opened it to the river story, and she read it aloud, and her voice was low and steady, and the twins listened, and Charity listened too, and the fire crackled, and the kettle sang, and Constance read about the river running clear, and about the love it carried, and about how it kept that love near, and Alice said the last line along with her, and Emma said it too, and they laughed, and Constance laughed, and she thought about how the story was the same story, no matter who read it, and how the words were the same words, and how the voice was different, and how the voice did not matter, because the story was what mattered, and the story was for all of them, and she closed the book, and she set it aside, and the afternoon went on.
In the evening, when the lamps were lit and the snow had stopped falling, the family sat down to supper, and the twins sat at the table, and they ate well, and they talked about the snowman, and they talked about the carrot, and they talked about the coal for his eyes, and Alice said, "Mama, the snowman is the biggest snowman in Aspen Hollow," and Emma said, "And Cherry helped us, Mama, and she rolled the