OFFICER SMASHED A BLACK WOMAN’S CAR WINDOW DURING A TRAFFIC STOP — THEN HIS SERGEANT PULLED UP

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Bennett asked Mitchell whether Cole had told Naomi the reason for the stop before Mitchell arrived. Mitchell said that, based on what he had heard and what Naomi had told him at the scene, Cole had not. He said Cole had told him, after the fact, that the stop was for failure to signal, but that Cole had not said that to Naomi before the window broke, and that the failure to communicate the reason was part of what had made the encounter dangerous. Bennett asked whether Mitchell had seen Naomi refuse an order to exit. Mitchell said he had not seen a refusal, because he had arrived after the window was already broken, but that he had seen Naomi's phone on the passenger seat with the call still active, and that Naomi had told him she had called dispatch because Cole had started yelling. Mitchell said he had believed her, not because he wanted to believe her, but because her account matched what he had seen: a woman who had called for help, not a woman who had been trying to escape.

Hale asked Mitchell about Cole's history. Mitchell paused, and Bennett watched him carefully, because this was the part where loyalty to a fellow officer could bend a report. Mitchell said that Cole had been warned before, by him, about raising his voice during stops and about moving too quickly from a verbal order to a physical action. He said there had been two prior complaints about aggressive stops, one that had been settled with retraining and one that had resulted in a written warning. He said he had spoken to Cole after the second complaint and had told him, in plain terms, that a badge did not make a raised voice safer, and that if Cole could not control the first minute of a stop, he would eventually lose control of the whole encounter. Mitchell said he had hoped the warning would be enough. He said that on the night of the window, it clearly had not been.

Cole's interview was different. He came in with a representative, sat with his hands flat on the table, and answered in short, practiced sentences. He said Naomi had refused a lawful order to exit the vehicle, that he had given the order twice, that he had warned her that he would break the window if she did not comply, and that the window break had been necessary to gain compliance. He said the stop had been for failure to signal, and that he had told Naomi that reason at the start of the stop. When Hale asked why his bodycam had not captured the start of the encounter, Cole said the camera had malfunctioned, that it had failed to activate, that he had reported the malfunction after the shift. When Hale asked why the cruiser dashcam showed a different sequence, Cole said the dashcam angle was limited and did not show Naomi's face or her hands clearly. When Hale asked about the dispatch call, Cole said he had not known Naomi was on the phone with dispatch until Mitchell noticed the phone, and that the call had not changed his assessment at the time because he had been focused on gaining compliance.

Hale did not argue with Cole in the room. He let Cole finish, and then he asked Cole to walk through the stop minute by minute, from the moment he first saw Naomi's sedan to the moment Mitchell ordered him to stand beside his cruiser. Cole's account stayed consistent on the main points, but it grew vague on the small ones: the exact wording of the first order, the exact distance between his patrol car and Naomi's sedan, the exact moment he had decided to use the baton. Hale noted the vagueness without pointing it out, because an investigation was built on records, not on winning an argument in a room. After Cole left, Hale told Bennett that the next step was not another interview. The next step was the audio, the video, and the witnesses, because those would either support Cole's version or contradict it, and they would do so without caring who wore a uniform.

The dispatch audio arrived first, and it changed the shape of the case. The operator who had taken Naomi's call, a woman named Denise Alvarez, had kept the recording intact and had written a short note at the time that she had not known would matter later. In the audio, Naomi's voice was shaking but clear. She said she was on the shoulder, that an officer was yelling at her, that she was afraid, and that she wanted to stay on the line. The operator could be heard telling her to stay in the vehicle, to keep her hands visible, and to tell the officer that she was on the phone with dispatch. There was no sound of Naomi refusing an order in the audio, because the audio began after Cole had already approached the car, and it captured the rising tension in his voice more clearly than it captured Naomi's words. Hale listened to it three times, once with his eyes closed, once while reading the transcript, and once while comparing the timestamps to the cruiser dashcam. The timestamps matched. The call had started before the first strike on the window, and it had still been active when Mitchell arrived. That meant Naomi had sought help before the glass broke, not after, and that she had done so while still sitting in her own car, with her hands where they could be seen.

News in the same category

OFFICER SMASHED A BLACK WOMAN’S CAR WINDOW DURING A TRAFFIC STOP — THEN HIS SERGEANT PULLED UP

45 Part