OFFICER SMASHED A BLACK WOMAN’S CAR WINDOW DURING A TRAFFIC STOP — THEN HIS SERGEANT PULLED UP

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The disciplinary hearing took place in a larger room than the internal affairs interviews, with a panel of three officers from outside Cole's direct chain of command, a hearing officer who ran the proceedings in a calm voice, and seats for witnesses along the back wall. Naomi arrived early with Maya and Priya, and she sat with her hands folded in her lap, wearing a dark blouse that was not burgundy, because she did not want to wear the color she had worn on the night of the stop. She did not look at Cole when he entered, and Cole did not look at her, but she felt his presence in the room the way she had felt it on the shoulder, as a weight that made her breathing shallow until she reminded herself to breathe in through her nose and out through her mouth. The hearing officer explained the process, that the panel would hear the internal affairs report, that witnesses would testify, that Cole would have the chance to respond, and that the panel would decide whether the violations had been proven and what discipline was appropriate. Naomi listened, and she thought about how different this room felt from the shoulder: there were no sirens, no baton, no glass, only chairs and paper and people who were required to listen.

Mitchell testified first, because his intervention was the reason the hearing existed at all. He walked to the witness seat in his uniform, gave his name and rank, and answered Hale's questions in the same steady voice he had used in his interview. He described arriving on the scene, seeing the broken window, seeing Cole reaching inside the vehicle, seeing Naomi covered in glass, and shouting Cole's name and ordering him to back away now. He described placing himself between Cole and Naomi's door, giving his name, and telling Naomi that he was not reaching into the vehicle. He described asking Cole what had happened, hearing Cole say that Naomi had refused a lawful order, hearing Naomi say that that was not what had happened, and telling Cole to stand beside his cruiser. He described asking Naomi what the original stop had been for, hearing her say that she did not know, hearing Cole say failure to signal from behind him, and noticing Naomi's phone on the passenger seat with the call still active. He described asking Naomi whether she had been on the phone with dispatch, and her answer, that she had called because Cole had started yelling. Mitchell did not embellish. He did not describe Cole as a bad person. He described actions, words, and sequence, and he let the panel draw its own conclusions.

When Cole's representative cross examined Mitchell, the questions were sharp but fair. Had Mitchell seen the start of the stop? No, Mitchell said, he had arrived after the window was broken. Had Mitchell seen Naomi refuse an order? No, he said, he had not, because he had not been there for that part. Had Mitchell assumed Cole had not told Naomi the reason? No, Mitchell said, he had based his conclusion on what Naomi had told him at the scene, on what Cole had said after the fact, and on the dispatch audio and the dashcam evidence that had since been reviewed. The representative asked whether Mitchell had shouted at Cole in front of a civilian, and whether that shouting had undermined Cole's authority. Mitchell said he had shouted Cole's name and ordered him to back away, because the situation required an immediate stop to the action, not a quiet conversation. He said authority that depended on not intervening when a civilian was hurt was not authority worth protecting. The panel members wrote notes, and one of them looked at Mitchell for a long moment after he finished, as if weighing not just his words, but his willingness to stand by them in a room where other officers were listening.

Naomi testified next, and Priya sat beside her table, not speaking, just present. Naomi told the panel what she had told Hale, in the same order, starting with the drive home, the signal, the lights, the shoulder, the hands on the wheel, the baton, the first strike, the second strike, the glass, the arm through the window, the hand reaching for the door handle, and her recoil toward the passenger seat. She told them about the phone call to dispatch, about Mitchell's arrival, about Mitchell giving his name and raising his hands where she could see them, about Cole saying she had refused an order, about her answer, about Mitchell telling Cole to stand beside his cruiser, and about her shoulders shaking only after Cole had walked away. She told them about the small cuts, about the glass in her hair, about the faint marks on her forearm, and about the sirens on her drive to work since then. She did not raise her voice. She did not cry, although her eyes filled once when she described the second strike, and she paused, breathed, and continued. When Cole's representative asked her whether she had refused to get out of the car, Naomi said no, that she had not been given a clear reason to get out before the window broke, and that she had been on the phone with dispatch because she was frightened. When the representative asked whether she had signaled, Naomi said yes, and that James Whitfield's dashcam showed it. When the representative asked whether she was seeking money, Naomi said she was seeking a record, and that Priya would handle any civil matter separately, but that in this hearing she was seeking a finding that what had happened was wrong. The panel thanked her, and Maya, who had been sitting in the back, wiped her eyes with the back of her hand and did not look away.

News in the same category

OFFICER SMASHED A BLACK WOMAN’S CAR WINDOW DURING A TRAFFIC STOP — THEN HIS SERGEANT PULLED UP

45 Part