OFFICER SMASHED A BLACK WOMAN’S CAR WINDOW DURING A TRAFFIC STOP — THEN HIS SERGEANT PULLED UP

Chapter 18

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Cole's supporters did not disappear while Naomi was in therapy and meeting with Priya. A few officers in the department began to tell a different story in private, that Naomi had been difficult, that she had argued, that Cole had been provoked, that Mitchell had overreacted by shouting in front of a civilian. One officer told Hale, off the record, that Cole was a good officer who had made a bad decision on a bad night, and that Naomi should have just gotten out of the car. Hale thanked him, wrote down the comment, and did not use it, because an off the record opinion was not evidence, and because the dispatch audio and the dashcam and Mitchell's bodycam were evidence. Another officer, who had worked with Cole for three years, told Hale on the record that Cole had a temper, that he had seen Cole raise his voice at drivers who asked questions, and that he had once seen Cole hit a car window with his hand, not a baton, during a stop that had ended without a complaint because the driver had not wanted to file one. That officer asked Hale not to use his name in the initial report, because he was afraid of retaliation, and Hale told him that his statement would be protected as far as the rules allowed, but that the truth of it would matter more than the fear around it.

Bennett called Mitchell into her office after the second week of the investigation and told him, directly, that she had received two informal complaints about him from officers who said he had undermined Cole on the scene. Bennett said she had dismissed both complaints, because Mitchell's bodycam showed an intervention to protect a civilian, not an undermining of a fellow officer, and because a sergeant who did not intervene when an officer was reaching through a broken window would have been failing in his duty. Mitchell thanked her, but he did not look relieved. He said he had been thinking about the stop every night since it happened, not because he doubted what he had done, but because he kept wondering whether he could have arrived sooner, whether he could have prevented the second strike, whether the first strike would have been enough to make him stop if he had been a minute earlier. Bennett told him that those questions were human, but that they were not the questions the investigation was asking. The investigation was asking what happened, what was recorded, and what the department would do about it. Mitchell nodded, and Bennett saw, for the first time, how tired he looked, not from the hours, but from carrying a truth that other people wanted him to soften.

The internal affairs finding came in a written report that Hale delivered to Bennett first, and then to Naomi and to Cole, on the same day, so that no one would hear it secondhand. The report found that Cole had violated the department's use of force policy by breaking Naomi's window without first communicating the reason for the stop, without giving her a clear and lawful order that she had refused, and without exhausting less forceful options. It found that the failure to signal claim was not supported by the dashcam evidence from James Whitfield's truck, which showed Naomi signaling before changing lanes. It found that Cole's bodycam had not malfunctioned, but had not been activated, and that the absence of footage was a separate policy violation. It found that Mitchell's intervention had been appropriate, timely, and consistent with his duty as a supervisor, and that his report had been truthful. It recommended that Cole be suspended without pay pending a disciplinary hearing, and that the department review its training on traffic stops, on communication before force, and on bodycam activation. Bennett read the report twice, signed it, and ordered that Cole be suspended that same afternoon. Cole was told in a short meeting, with his representative present, that he was suspended, that his badge and weapon would be held, and that he would have the right to a hearing. He did not argue in the meeting. He asked only whether Mitchell had written the report, and Bennett said no, that the report had been written by internal affairs, based on evidence, and that Mitchell's role had been to tell the truth at the scene and in his interview, which he had done.

Naomi received the finding at home, with Maya beside her. She read it slowly, twice, and then she sat quietly for a long time. Maya asked whether she felt relieved. Naomi said she felt something closer to tired relief, the kind that comes not from winning, but from being believed on paper. She said she was glad the report had named the things that had actually happened: the missing reason, the signal that had been given, the call to dispatch, the window, the intervention. She said she was also aware that a report was not an ending, because Cole would have a hearing, and because a hearing would mean testifying again, in a room with Cole present, and answering questions from people whose job it was to test her memory. Maya said she would be there, in the hallway if not in the room, and that Naomi did not have to be brave in a way that looked brave to other people. She only had to be steady enough to tell the truth again. Naomi nodded, and that night she slept longer than she had since the stop, not because the investigation was over, but because, for the first time, the official record matched what she remembered.

News in the same category

OFFICER SMASHED A BLACK WOMAN’S CAR WINDOW DURING A TRAFFIC STOP — THEN HIS SERGEANT PULLED UP

45 Part