OFFICER SMASHED A BLACK WOMAN’S CAR WINDOW DURING A TRAFFIC STOP — THEN HIS SERGEANT PULLED UP

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Mitchell listened from a few feet away, and he made no move to hurry her. He had already called for a tow truck for the sedan, because the window could not be left open to the road and because Naomi should not have to drive home with glass on the seat and wind cutting through the frame. He had also called for another officer, not to take over the scene, but to stand as a witness while he documented it. When Officer Priya Raman arrived, Mitchell spoke to her quietly, away from Cole, and asked her to photograph the car before anything was moved. Raman used her department phone and then a second camera, taking wide shots of the sedan on the shoulder, close shots of the spiderwebbed frame and the shattered opening, the baton still in Cole's hand, the glass scattered across the burgundy blouse Naomi had not yet changed, the leather seat, the center console, and the floor.

"Get the phone too," Mitchell said. "Screen lit, call active, if you can do it without touching the call itself."

Raman photographed Naomi's phone where it lay on the passenger seat, the dispatch number visible, the timer still running. Naomi had not hung up. The dispatcher had stayed on the line through the shouting, through the second strike, through Mitchell's arrival, and the recording would later show that Naomi had not screamed threats, had not cursed at Cole in a way that could be twisted into aggression, had simply said, again and again, that she was scared and that she wanted someone to stay with her on the line. Mitchell did not listen to the whole recording at the roadside. He did not need to. He needed to preserve it, and he said so out loud, so that Raman and Cole and Naomi could all hear the same words.

"Cole's body camera, dash camera, and radio traffic are to be preserved," Mitchell said, looking directly at Cole, who was standing beside his cruiser with his arms crossed and his jaw set. "No one deletes, edits, or reviews them alone. They go to internal affairs with my report. Understood?"

Cole nodded once, too sharply to be agreement and too slowly to be defiance. He looked at the sedan, at the glass, at Naomi with the blanket now around her shoulders, and for a moment his face did something complicated, as if he were trying to decide which version of the story would be easiest to live with. Then he looked away, toward the traffic moving past in the other lane, and said nothing.

Mitchell turned back to Naomi. "Ma'am, I need to ask you what happened, in your own words, while it's fresh. You can stop at any time. You can have someone with you. Officer Raman will take notes, and I'll write my own report separately. If you don't remember something exactly, say so. Don't guess to fill a gap."

Naomi took a breath, in through her nose, out through her mouth, the way she had forced herself to breathe when she did not want Cole to see her shake. She told it plainly, without raising her voice to match the memory of his. She had been driving home. She had signaled before changing lanes. She had not been speeding. She had pulled over promptly when she saw the lights. Cole had approached without giving a reason for the stop. He had told her to get out. She had asked why, because she did not understand what she had done, and because asking why had always seemed, to her, like a reasonable thing for a person to do when a stranger with a badge and a baton told her to leave the safety of her car. Cole had raised his voice. She had become frightened, not defiant, and she had called dispatch because she wanted a witness who was not standing on the shoulder with a baton. She had not reached for anything. She had not threatened him. She had not refused to exit after being given a lawful reason, because no lawful reason had been given until Mitchell arrived and asked Cole himself what the stop was for, and Cole had said, from behind Mitchell, "Failure to signal."

"That is not true," Naomi said, and her voice steadied as she said it. "I signaled. I remember signaling because I always check before I move over, especially at night. He never told me that at my window. He just yelled."

Mitchell wrote that down, word for word as best he could, and Raman wrote it down too. He did not argue with her, did not suggest that she might have misremembered, did not soften her account to make it easier for the department. He asked only clarifying questions: what time had she left work, which lane had she been in, where exactly had the patrol car been when the lights came on, had she touched her phone before or after Cole raised the baton. Naomi answered each one, and when she did not know an exact time, she said so, and Mitchell wrote "does not recall exact time" instead of inventing one for her.

Cole, from beside his cruiser, called out, "She refused a lawful order. That's in my report already."

News in the same category

OFFICER SMASHED A BLACK WOMAN’S CAR WINDOW DURING A TRAFFIC STOP — THEN HIS SERGEANT PULLED UP

45 Part