He remembered Peter standing in his office, holding the thin folder against his chest. He remembered the exhaustion in the young man's eyes and the fear he had tried to conceal. He remembered how carefully Peter had chosen his words, as though every sentence might be used against him later.
“Yes,” William said. “He was a good man. He cared deeply about whether the truth was being told, even when telling it made his life more difficult.”
Emily exhaled shakily.
“Thank you. I needed to hear that from someone who knew him.”
“Your father deserved better than to spend his life worrying that the work he did would disappear. We'll do our best to understand what he left behind.”
They arranged to speak again that afternoon. Before ending the call, Emily promised to keep the papers secure and to tell her mother about the conversation before making any decisions.
William put the phone away.
For several seconds, neither he nor Claire spoke.
Then Claire said, “This is no longer just about the messages or the records request.”
“No,” William replied. “But it still doesn't prove that any of these things are connected.”
“What do you think we should do?”
“We should meet Emily, document what she has, and involve an independent archivist or investigator. We should also tell Investigator Chen that Peter's daughter has contacted us, without suggesting that we know what the connection is.”
Claire nodded.
“And if someone is trying to obtain those records before we can examine them?”
“Then we need to make sure the original evidence is preserved and that no one person controls access to it.”
William opened the car door but did not get inside immediately.
He thought about the anonymous messages, the unfamiliar vehicle outside his house, the old photograph, and Peter's warning about the dates. Each piece was troubling on its own. Together, they suggested that someone might be trying to keep an old story from being told.
But William had spent too many years in medicine to mistake a collection of symptoms for a confirmed diagnosis.
The truth would require patience.
It would require independent verification, honest witnesses, and the willingness to accept findings that might complicate his assumptions.
Above all, it would require protecting people who had already paid a price for asking questions.
As he finally sat behind the wheel, his phone vibrated again.
This time, the message came from an unfamiliar email address.
There was no greeting, no signature, and no explanation.
Only one sentence:
“Ask Emily what happened to the original copy of Case 21-A.”
William read it twice.
Then he showed it to Claire.
Neither of them spoke for a long moment.
Because Case 21-A was the final reference he had written in his old notebook before the meetings with Peter Lawson stopped.
And beside that reference, in William's own handwriting, were the words:
The witness never arrived.
William read the email again, then enlarged the message on his phone to inspect the sender's address. It was a string of random letters and numbers, routed through a service that revealed almost nothing about the person who had sent it.
“Whoever wrote this knows about the notebook,” Claire said.
“Or they know enough about the program to guess which cases I reviewed.”
“They also know Emily has contacted you.”
William looked at her.
“We haven't told anyone about that conversation.”
“Which means the information may have come from somewhere else. Or the sender is bluffing.”
“Then we don't assume either possibility is true until we have evidence.”
Claire took a photograph of the screen with her own phone, then asked William to forward the email without deleting the original. She reminded him not to click any attachments or links that might arrive later. When they had preserved the message, she called the foundation's information technology consultant and asked him to record the relevant details.
Only after those steps were complete did William start the car.
“Case 21-A,” he said quietly. “I can remember the meeting, but not the witness.”
“Let's start with what you do remember.”
He drove out of the parking garage and merged into traffic.
“The case involved a man who had been detained after an incident outside an apartment building. I believe he was taken to a hospital before being transferred to a holding facility. There was a dispute about whether his injuries occurred before or after he was restrained.”
“And the witness?”
“A woman, possibly a resident of the building. She was supposed to provide a statement about what she saw.”
“Did she ever give one?”
“I don't know. The last note I made says she never arrived.”
Claire studied him.
“Could that mean she failed to attend an interview? Or that she never reached the office?”
“Both are possible. I would need to see the original file.”
“Where was it kept?”
“The program archive. At least, that was where it was supposed to be.”
“And if the file is missing?”
William kept his eyes on the road.
“Then we find out who last had access to it.”
They drove to the foundation, where Claire arranged a private meeting room for their conversation with Emily Lawson that afternoon. William then spent the next two hours reviewing his old notebooks, trying to reconstruct the sequence of events surrounding Case 21-A.
The records offered frustratingly little.
There was a reference to a hospital report, a note about a missing witness statement, and a reminder to contact Peter Lawson. A few pages later, William had written that the case had been transferred for administrative review.
There was no final conclusion.
He checked the index of cases from the same year. Case 14-B had a closure date. Case 18-D had a transfer date. Case 21-A had neither.
Instead, someone had drawn a thin line through the reference number.
The ink was darker than the surrounding entries.