He chose a table near the window, ordered tea, and opened his notebook.
The case was beginning to take shape, but not in the way he had expected. The missing witness statement was only one part of a larger puzzle. There had been restricted supplemental materials, unexplained transfers, a recent request from the county executive's office, and a man who seemed determined to remind him that old cases could harm innocent people.
William wrote three names on a fresh page.
Robert Voss.
Daniel Mercer.
The unnamed witness.
He drew a circle around the third.
Whatever the other two knew, the witness remained the key. If she had kept her original statement, she might be able to confirm whether the official investigation had accurately represented what happened.
But finding her would not be easy.
The witness's name had been missing from the incomplete records William had seen. The photograph showed only a woman standing outside the hospital. He did not know where she had lived, whether she had changed her name, or whether she was still alive.
He needed another route.
He began with the hospital itself.
The county hospital had been reorganized twice since the incident. Several departments had moved, and the original medical records office had been replaced by a regional records service. But the hospital's public history collection might contain staff directories, archived annual reports, or photographs from the period.
William finished his tea and drove there.
The hospital had grown considerably since his last visit. A new emergency entrance faced the main road, and glass corridors connected buildings that had once stood apart. The old administration wing remained at the rear of the property, partially hidden behind newer construction.
He parked near the entrance and walked to the information desk.
After explaining that he was researching a historical case, he was directed to the hospital's records liaison office.
The liaison, a middle-aged man named Peter Lawson, listened patiently as William described what he was looking for.
"Do you have a patient number?" Lawson asked.
"No. I'm trying to identify a witness, not locate a patient's chart."
"Then the historical records office might be more appropriate. Unfortunately, most personnel records from that period were transferred to the county."
"What about incident reports?"
"Those may have been retained here, depending on the department."
William supplied the approximate date and case number.
Lawson entered the information into his system.
"I can see a reference to an internal review," he said. "The report itself isn't available through this database."
"Does the reference identify anyone involved?"
Lawson leaned closer to the screen.
"There's a notation about an employee interview."
"Who was interviewed?"
"The name isn't displayed here. It says the interview record was stored separately."
"Where?"
"Possibly in the legal department's archive."
William felt a flicker of hope.
"Can we request it?"
"We can submit a request, but I should warn you that records connected to litigation or personnel disputes may be restricted."
"I understand."
Lawson printed a request form.
As William completed it, the liaison looked at him thoughtfully.
"May I ask why you're investigating this now?"
William considered giving a vague answer, but Lawson's tone was not suspicious. He sounded genuinely curious.
"Because I believe someone may have been denied a fair hearing," William said. "And because the records don't appear to agree with one another."
Lawson nodded slowly.
"That happens more often than people realize. A report is written, then summarized, then summarized again. Each version removes a little detail. Eventually, the summary becomes the official story, and nobody remembers what was in the original document."
"Have you seen that happen here?"
"Not with this case. I wasn't working in this department at the time."
Lawson hesitated.
"But there was an old records clerk who used to complain about missing attachments. She retired years ago. She said the summaries were often present when the original documents weren't."
William leaned forward.
"Do you remember her name?"
"Margaret Ellis."
The name meant nothing to him, but it was a lead.
"Do you know where she lives?"
"No. But the hospital alumni association might have a contact address. I can check whether she's still listed."
Lawson made a few calls. After several minutes, he returned with a small piece of paper.
"I found an old address. I can't guarantee it's current."
William thanked him.
Before leaving, he asked whether Lawson could confirm the existence of the separately stored interview record.
"I've submitted the request," Lawson said. "It may take a few days."
"Please let me know as soon as you hear anything."
"I will."
Outside, William stood beside his car and studied the address.
It was in a residential neighborhood on the northern side of the city, about twenty minutes away.
He decided to go there immediately.
The street was quiet, lined with mature trees and modest brick houses. Several properties had small gardens, and children’s bicycles lay on the sidewalks in front of two homes. Margaret Ellis's address led him to a narrow house with faded green shutters and a wooden gate that hung slightly crooked.
He rang the bell.
No one answered.
He waited, then rang again.
A curtain moved in the front window.
An elderly woman appeared behind the glass. She watched him for several seconds before opening the door a few inches.
"Yes?"
"Mrs. Ellis? My name is William. I used to work as a physician at the county hospital. I'm researching an old case involving an internal review, and your name came up as someone who worked with archived records."
Her expression changed.
Not dramatically, but enough.
"I don't discuss hospital business anymore."
"I understand. I'm not asking you to reveal confidential medical information. I'm trying to determine whether an original witness statement was separated from an official report."
Margaret tightened her grip on the door.
"Which case?"
William gave her the case number.