She was Lieutenant Rebecca Morgan, a supervisor from the same department. Her uniform was immaculate, her dark hair tied back, and her expression unreadable.
“What's going on, Daniel?”
Sullivan's posture changed immediately.
“Lieutenant. I encountered a suspicious individual beside a luxury vehicle. He became verbally confrontational, refused to cooperate, and obstructed my investigation.”
Morgan glanced at William.
“Is he under arrest?”
“I'm still determining the situation.”
“You just told dispatch he was detained for obstruction.”
Sullivan hesitated.
“He was interfering with my investigation.”
Morgan turned to William.
“Sir, can you tell me what happened?”
William met her eyes.
“My name is Dr. William Avery. I parked my vehicle outside the store and intended to purchase something. Officer Sullivan approached me and asked what I was doing. I explained that I was making a purchase. He asked for my receipt, although I had not bought anything. When I asked why he was questioning me, he grabbed my jacket.”
Morgan listened without interrupting.
William continued.
“I asked him to explain the legal basis for detaining me. He did not. He repeatedly ordered me to obey him, grabbed my wrist, pushed me against my car, and handcuffed me. I did not strike him, threaten him, or attempt to flee.”
Morgan looked at Sullivan.
“Is that accurate?”
“That's his version.”
“I'm asking whether you used force.”
“He was being difficult.”
“Did you use force?”
Sullivan's jaw tightened.
“I placed him against the vehicle to maintain control of the situation.”
Morgan glanced at William's wrists.
“Remove the handcuffs.”
Sullivan looked startled.
“Lieutenant, I haven't finished my investigation.”
“Then continue it without restraining him, unless you have a lawful reason to do otherwise. What is the suspected offense?”
“Obstruction.”
“What specific act?”
“He refused to answer questions.”
Morgan stared at him.
“People are not generally required to answer every question an officer asks them. What else?”
“He questioned my authority and became argumentative.”
“Did he threaten you?”
“No.”
“Did he strike you?”
“No.”
“Did he attempt to flee?”
Sullivan did not answer immediately.
“No.”
Morgan held out her hand.
“Key.”
For a moment, Sullivan seemed unwilling to move. Then he took the key from his pocket and placed it in her palm.
Morgan unlocked the cuffs herself.
William slowly brought his hands forward. Red marks circled both wrists, and his right hand trembled slightly as he flexed his fingers.
Claire stepped toward him.
“Are you hurt?”
“My shoulder is painful, and my wrists are sore.”
“We should have you examined.”
“Perhaps,” William replied. “But first I would like to understand why I was detained.”
Morgan nodded.
“That is a fair question. I will review the circumstances and make sure the incident is documented. I also want the witnesses' contact information.”
Marcus lowered his phone just enough to speak.
“I have a recording of the entire encounter.”
“Please preserve the original file,” Morgan said. “Don't edit it. Make a backup if you can, and provide a copy through the appropriate process.”
“I will.”
Helen stepped forward.
“I saw everything from the beginning. The officer approached him while he was standing beside his car. Dr. Avery wasn't doing anything suspicious.”
Morgan gave her a card.
“Thank you. Please write down what you remember while the details are fresh.”
The elderly man who had been holding the coffee introduced himself as Thomas Greene. He had watched most of the encounter from the sidewalk and confirmed that William had never attempted to attack Sullivan.
Morgan recorded his name as well.
Sullivan stood apart from the group, his face dark with anger.
William noticed that the officer had not apologized.
He had not expected one, but the absence still hurt.
A simple acknowledgment would have meant something. A sentence admitting that the situation had gone too far. A recognition that the person standing in front of him was a human being rather than a problem to be controlled.
Instead, Sullivan looked at William as though the entire incident had been caused by his refusal to make himself smaller.
Morgan turned to the officer.
“Daniel, I want you to return to the station and prepare a complete report. Include the initial reason for contact, the actions you took, the statements you heard, and the reason you believed detention was justified. Do not discuss your account with other witnesses.”
Sullivan stiffened.
“Am I being investigated?”
“I am directing you to complete your report. If further review is necessary, you'll be informed.”
He looked toward William.
“This is ridiculous.”
Morgan's voice became sharper.
“That's enough. Return to your vehicle.”
Sullivan walked away.
Before getting into his cruiser, he turned back once and looked at Marcus. The expression on his face was not one of regret. It was a promise that the confrontation had not ended for him.
Marcus noticed it.
So did William.
But neither man said anything.
When Sullivan drove away, the tension on the street began to loosen. Helen wiped her eyes. Thomas retrieved his coffee. A few people who had gathered at the edge of the sidewalk slowly returned to their errands.
Claire helped William straighten his jacket.
“Your shoulder should be examined,” she said. “I can take you to the clinic.”
“I appreciate that.”
“And we need to preserve the evidence. The video, the photographs, the witness statements, the dispatch records, and the officer's report.”
William nodded.
“Agreed.”
Morgan approached them before they could leave.
“Dr. Avery, I'm sorry this happened. I can't determine the full circumstances on the sidewalk, and I won't make promises before reviewing the evidence. But I will make sure the incident is documented and that the available recordings are preserved.”
William studied her face.
“Lieutenant, I don't expect you to reach a conclusion before you've examined the facts. I only ask that you examine all of them.”
“I will.”
“And please remember something. I am not the only person who might have been treated this way. If the only reason this encounter receives attention is that someone recognizes my name, then we will have learned very little.”