“Then we should make sure the records are examined carefully.”
She nodded, wiped her eyes, and returned the notebook to its protective sleeve.
Before she left, Claire explained how they could arrange for an independent archivist to create a secure inventory of the papers. Emily agreed, provided that her mother could decide whether to participate and that no original documents would be transferred without a written agreement.
William thanked her for trusting them.
As she stood to go, she turned back.
“There's one more thing I haven't told you.”
William waited.
“Two weeks ago, someone came to my mother's house. A man in a gray suit. He said he was reviewing the records of retired county employees and wanted to ask her about my father's work.”
“Did he identify himself?”
“He showed her an identification card, but she couldn't remember the name. She said he was polite. He asked whether my father had kept private copies of official documents.”
William felt the same cold pressure he had felt when he read the anonymous message.
“What did your mother tell him?”
“She said she didn't know. Then he asked about a box my father had stored in the attic. My mother said the box was still there, but she hadn't opened it.”
“Did he ask to see it?”
“Yes.”
“Did she let him?”
Emily shook her head.
“No. She told him she needed to speak to me first. He left a card, but she couldn't find it afterward.”
Claire wrote down the details.
“Did he return?”
“Not that I know of.”
William looked at Emily carefully.
“Do you think he took anything from the house?”
“I don't know. My mother says she didn't notice anything missing, but she hasn't checked the attic.”
“Please don't search the attic alone. If you decide to inspect the box, arrange for someone you trust to be with you. Take photographs before moving anything, and make a record of what you find.”
Emily nodded.
“Do you think someone is trying to steal the documents?”
“I don't know,” William said. “But several people have now asked about records connected to your father. That makes it important to preserve them properly.”
She looked frightened again.
“Should I call the police?”
“Tell Investigator Chen what you've told us. She can advise you on the appropriate steps, and she will have a record of the contact. If you believe someone is in immediate danger, contact emergency services. Otherwise, let's document the facts and avoid making assumptions.”
Emily agreed.
After she left, Claire sat quietly for a moment, reviewing her notes.
“The same question keeps appearing,” she said. “Who has the original records?”
“And who benefits if they disappear.”
“We can't answer that yet.”
“No.”
William returned to the notebook and studied the initials.
M. Ellis.
He tried to remember whether he had ever seen that name in the old program records. It seemed familiar, but he could not place it.
Claire began searching the information available through the foundation's legitimate research resources, looking for public references to the old case and the people who had worked in the relevant departments. She found no reliable record that directly identified the witness.
After nearly an hour, she closed her laptop.
“If M. Ellis was never formally listed in the case register, a public search may tell us nothing.”
“Then we need the original archive.”
“Investigator Chen is already looking into it.”
William nodded, though waiting felt increasingly difficult.
He thought of the witness as a real person rather than a line in an old notebook. A woman had apparently spoken to Peter Lawson outside the formal process. She had been frightened enough that he had decided not to leave her name in the office copy. Whatever she had seen, she had chosen to preserve her own statement rather than trust the system that was supposed to receive it.
And now, decades later, people were asking where that statement had gone.
At three twenty, Chen called again.
“I've received the email you forwarded,” she said. “We're treating it as potentially relevant, but I need to be clear that we have not established who sent it or why.”
“Understood.”
“I've also confirmed that Case 21-A appears in an older index, but the main file is incomplete. The surviving record contains references to a witness whose statement is not present in the file.”
William sat forward.
“Is the witness identified?”
“Not in the copy I reviewed. There is a reference to a supplementary contact sheet, but we haven't located it.”
“Could the contact sheet contain the name M. Ellis?”
“I can't say without seeing it.”
“Do you know who last accessed the file?”
“Not yet. The old tracking system was inconsistent, and some entries were recorded manually. We're looking at the available logs.”
William told her about Emily's notebook and the reference to a witness who had retained the original statement.
Chen was silent for a moment.
“That is important information. Please send me a description of the entry and the date recorded. Don't send the original notebook unless we have a documented transfer process.”
“Claire is preparing the information.”
“Good. I also need to tell you that the archived records request has been temporarily suspended while we establish its scope and authorization.”
“Who suspended it?”
“I did.”
William exhaled slowly.
“Thank you.”
“I haven't solved anything, Dr. Avery. I've only paused the request until we understand it.”
“Sometimes that's the necessary first step.”
Chen continued.
“One more thing. The initial request included a phrase that doesn't appear in the standard digitization forms. It asked for ‘all surviving original witness materials and personal supplements associated with unresolved files.’”
William looked at Claire.
“Personal supplements?”
“That is the phrase used,” Chen said. “I am trying to determine who added it and why.”