"Then we will meet your judge," Greta said. "In a courtroom, with our papers in order, which is more than Mr. Slate ever brought to one. But you will not freeze this town's notes in the meantime, Mr. Pierce, because those notes are backed by the first ore shipment, which the miners dug with their own hands after your client was taken away, and no judge in this territory is going to tell working men that their labor is not an asset."
Karl Weber stood. "The miners stand behind the charter," he said. "Every man who went back down the shaft after Slate fell did it on the council's word. If you freeze the notes, you freeze their wages, and you will answer for that in Denver, not just in this room."
Pierce turned his attention to Greta then, the way a man turns to the one opponent he thinks he can wound. "Mrs. Holt," he said, "before we discuss the charter, perhaps the council should know who it is following. Your late husband signed a petition in support of Mr. Slate. A matter of public record, I believe, since you were kind enough to publish it yourself. Does the council know that its chair comes from a household that stood with my client?"
The room went still, and Kane felt his hands curl into fists at his sides, because he knew this move. He had watched Slate's men make it a dozen times: find the one true thing a person is ashamed of, and hold it up until the room forgets everything else about them.
But Greta smiled, and it was not a frightened smile. It was the smile of a woman whose worst paper had already been read aloud in this very room.
"Mr. Pierce," she said, "that petition is in our claims register, on an open shelf, where you are welcome to read it yourself. I put it there. I read it to this council before you arrived, and this council kept me as chair anyway. You have come a long way from Denver to tell us something we already know, and I am afraid you will have to do better than that."
Kane had to look down at his boots for a moment, because the pride he felt in that instant was almost embarrassing in its size. He had confessed worse things in this room than a signature on a petition, and Greta had made a rule that let him live here afterward. Now she was living under the same rule, in front of the same people, and the rule was holding.
Pierce, to his credit, did not bluster. He gathered his papers with care, the way a man gathers a hand he intends to play again later, and he said, "Then the matter will be decided by a court, and courts cost money. Can this town afford a defense, Mrs. Holt? Can it afford to fight Mr. Slate's estate in Denver while its mine sits idle?"
It was the right question, and it was the question Kane had been afraid of since the carriage rolled in. A town could have papers and unity and still be bled dry by legal fees, and Slate's estate had deeper pockets than any ten Timberlines.
Greta did not answer at once. She looked around the room, and Kane saw her doing the arithmetic in her head, the way she did arithmetic at the post office counter: slowly, honestly, and out loud.
"We will raise a defense fund," she said. "Not by taxing people who have nothing, but by subscription, the way we paid for the road repairs. Anyone who gives will have their name written in a book, and anyone who reads that book will know what this town was willing to pay for."
Ike Banner was the first to stand. "The store will pledge fifty dollars in credit," he said, "and I'll carry the town's accounts at cost until the case is heard. I did business with Slate for years, and I will not do business against this town now."
Karl Weber stood next. "The miners will pledge a share of the next shipment," he said. "Not all of it — the men have families — but a share, voted in the shaft meeting, and written down."
Elsa Acker stood at the back, and her voice was quiet, but the room heard it, because rooms always hear Elsa Acker. "I have four dollars," she said. "It is not much. But it is mine, and it is not Slate's, and I would rather spend it defending this town than spend it anywhere else."