Hal Boren. Twelve dollars in company scrip, March of last year, for word of a miners' meeting at the storehouse. Eight dollars, June, for the names of men talking about a petition. Fifteen dollars, September, for warning that Karl Weber was carrying a letter to the territorial governor's office.
Hal Boren, who had stood in the council meetings all summer with his fist on the table and demanded that Deputy Kane be driven out of Timberline in disgrace. Hal Boren, who had called mercy a luxury the town could not afford. Hal Boren, who had shouted, only last week, that any man who had taken Slate's money ought to be run off his land and never allowed back.
Greta folded the papers, put them back in their envelope, and slid the envelope into the drawer where she kept the claims register. Then she went on sorting the mail, because her hands needed something honest to do while her mind worked. Finn glanced at her once, twice, and then kept his questions to himself, which was one of the reasons she trusted him with the post office at seventeen.
She had made a rule, back in the spring, when Deputy Kane stood before the town and confessed what he had done under Slate's orders. She had said it aloud, in front of the whole council, and the town had argued over it for three nights before accepting it: confession plus restitution work, not blood. No man would be hanged by rumor. No man would be driven out for what he had done under Slate, if he would stand up, say it plainly, and work to repair it. Kane had repaired roofs and fences all summer under that rule, and the town, slowly, had learned to nod to him on the street again.
The rule had been easy to defend when it sheltered a man like Kane, who had come forward on his own. It was a different matter when it sheltered a man who had hidden, and who had spent the summer pointing at other men's sins to keep his own out of sight.
Greta closed the post office at noon and walked out to Boren's farm. It was a two-mile walk along the creek road, and she took it slowly, because she wanted to arrive with her temper cooled and her purpose clear. The Boren place was a good farm, or had been: a square house, a barn with a new-looking roof, a field of wheat gone pale gold in the late-summer sun. Boren's wife was hanging washing in the yard, and his two sons were mending a fence at the far end of the field. Boren himself was on the porch, sharpening a scythe, and he looked up at her approach with the open, easy face of a man who had nothing to fear from the postmistress.
"Greta," he said, setting the scythe down. "You walked all this way. Something wrong with the mail?"
"Something wrong with the town's memory, Hal," she said. "Can we talk inside?"
His face changed then, just a fraction, the way a man's face changes when he hears his own name spoken in a tone he has not earned. He followed her into the kitchen, and his wife, reading something in Greta's manner, took the washing basket and went out to the yard without a word.
Greta laid the copied list on the table between them, folded open to the second page, and watched him read it. She watched the color leave his cheeks and then come back in a rush, and she watched his big farmer's hands curl into fists on the tabletop and then slowly, slowly open again.
"Where did you get this?" he said, very quietly.
"From the territory," she said. "From Slate's own papers. It is a copy, Hal. The original is in the territorial clerk's office, and anyone in this town can write and ask for one."
He stared at the page for a long time. Outside, one of his sons laughed at something, a bright, ordinary sound, and Boren flinched as if the sound had struck him.
"I never took their money for myself," he said at last. "Not for myself. You have to believe that."
"Then tell me what you took it for," Greta said. She kept her voice level, the way she kept it level when a man came to the post-office window shouting about a lost letter. "Tell me plainly, because the town will hear this, one way or another, and it is better that they hear it from you."