By midday the line at the post office had thinned, and the arguments had begun in earnest, the way arguments in Timberline always began: not with shouting, but with men standing in the street with their hands in their pockets, talking low and hard. Karl found himself in the middle of one before he knew how he had gotten there, facing a knot of miners who had worked the Silver King since before Slate's time, men whose faces he knew from the shaft the way a man knows his own tools.
One of them, a broad man with a scar through his eyebrow, shook his head at Karl. "Shares," he said, as if the word itself were a trick. "Slate sold us shares once, Karl. Paper shares, in a company that never paid a dividend, while he took the silver out the back door. Now you want us to buy the mine we already dug with our own hands? That sounds like paying a man for the privilege of digging his own grave twice."
Karl had heard this argument before, in the shaft, in the council, in his own head at night. He answered it the way he had learned to answer hard things since the fall: plainly, and without pretending the past had not happened.
"You're right that Slate sold paper," he said. "This is not Slate's paper. This paper says the town holds the lease, and the royalty goes into a trust for the old claims, and no man is paid in scrip, and the safety rules are written into the lease where no boss can quietly cross them out. I read every line of it with Greta, twice. If you don't trust the paper, trust this: you will hold your share in your own hand, and you will vote every year on who runs the mine, and if the men who run it cheat you, you can throw them out without asking Denver's permission. Slate never offered you that. Slate offered you scrip and a locked door."
The scarred miner stared at him, then spat thoughtfully into the dust. "I'll vote for the charter," he said at last. "The shares — I'll think on it till the count is done. But I'll be watching that lease, Karl. So will every man here."
"Good," Karl said. "Watch it. That's what it's for."
He was still turning that conversation over in his mind when Finn came running from the post office with a letter in his hand, sealed with a Denver lawyer's wax. Karl felt his stomach drop before he even saw the name on it. Stanton Pierce. The letter was short, and it was written in the smooth, confident hand of a man accustomed to being obeyed: the vote, Pierce wrote, was unlawful; the town had no standing to dispose of assets under injunction; any lease signed would be void; any man who signed it would answer personally in a territorial court.
Karl carried the letter to Greta, who read it standing at the post-office counter, with the ballot box beside her and the line of voters watching. She read it twice, folded it, and laid it on the counter where everyone could see the seal.
"Mr. Pierce writes well," she said, in a voice that carried to the back of the room. "But Mr. Pierce writes from Denver, about a town he has never lived in, concerning a charter that has already been filed with the territory and a governor's letter that says this town may administer its own affairs. The injunction froze Ezekiel Slate's assets. It did not freeze Timberline. We will vote today, and we will keep the letter, and if Mr. Pierce wishes to argue the matter further, he may argue it in front of the same territorial clerk who recorded our charter."
She pinned Pierce's letter to the wall beside the tally sheet, where it hung all afternoon like a warning and like a trophy at once, and the voting went on, steadier if anything, because nothing sharpens a town's purpose like being told it has none.
Late in the afternoon a rider came in from Denver with a letter, and for one cold moment Karl thought it was Pierce, back with another paper to stop them. It was not. It was a letter from the territorial clerk's office, confirming that the town's charter filing had been received and recorded, and that the town's claim to administer its own affairs pending the Slate proceedings was, in the clerk's careful phrase, "not disputed at this time." Greta read it aloud to the room, and a cheer went up that startled the horses outside.