When it was over, people filed out slowly, in twos and threes, talking in low voices, and Karl stayed behind with Greta while she stacked the chairs.
"You didn't want that chair," he said.
"No," she said. "I wanted to go back to my counter and sort the mail. But the mail doesn't sort itself into a town, Karl. Somebody has to do the other work too."
"Will it hold?" he asked. "What we did today — will it hold?"
She looked at the empty circle of chairs, and at the blackboard with its half-erased alphabet, and at the door through which Deputy Kane had just walked out alone into the street.
"I don't know," she said honestly. "But it's written down now. Hal's anger is written down. The woman's fear is written down. Your petition is written down. And things that are written down are harder to pretend away. That's a start. That's all a start ever is."
Karl walked out into the street with her, and the light was thin and late, and the mine still stood silent on the ridge. But for the first time since Slate's wagon had rolled away, Karl had the feeling that Timberline was not just a place where something had ended. It was a place where something — uncertain, quarrelsome, fragile, and entirely their own — had just begun.
But the meeting was not truly over when the chairs were stacked. It went on, the way all real meetings do, in doorways and on boardwalks, in the low voices of people who had not dared to speak inside the circle.
Karl found Hal Boren outside the schoolhouse, standing beside his farm wagon with his arms still crossed, staring up at the ridge where the mine stood silent. Karl had known Hal for ten years, had worked beside his sons in the harvest before the mine took them, had eaten at his table. He knew Hal's anger was not a pose. He also knew, in the way you know things about a neighbor without ever being told, that Hal's anger had a second root, one Hal himself would not name: shame. In Slate's years, Hal had kept his farm by keeping quiet, and quiet, over time, had curdled into something he could no longer live with. Now that Slate was gone, Hal wanted someone else to carry the weight he had carried, and Kane was the nearest man to hand it to.
"Hal," Karl said, and stopped beside the wagon.
"Don't, Karl," Hal said, without looking at him. "Don't tell me about mercy. I've heard enough about mercy for one morning."
"I'm not here to tell you about mercy," Karl said. "I'm here to tell you about arithmetic. You want Kane gone. Fine. Who digs the new well if he goes? Who repairs the bridge before the snow? The town has twelve able-bodied men who aren't already broken by the mine, Hal, and Kane is one of them. You can have your vengeance, or you can have a bridge. You can't have both before winter."
Hal was quiet for a long moment, and his jaw worked, and Karl saw something cross his face that was not quite anger and not quite grief.
"My boy," Hal said at last, very quietly, "asked me once why I never stood up to Slate. He was fourteen. He asked it the way children ask things they don't know are knives. I told him to mind his business. He's in Denver now. He doesn't write." Hal looked at Karl then, and his eyes were wet, which embarrassed them both. "I don't want Kane punished, Karl. I want somebody to be punished. Because if nobody is punished, then what was it all for? What did we endure it for?"
Karl did not have an answer for that, and he did not pretend to. He put a hand on Hal's shoulder, and Hal did not shake it off, and they stood there for a while, two men looking up at a silent mine, neither of them saying the thing they both knew: that punishment would not bring Hal's boy home, and that the town would have to find a different answer, or it would tear itself apart looking for one.