Hal sat, slowly, like a man lowering something heavy. But his eyes stayed on Kane.
A woman Karl did not know well — a miner's wife with a baby on her hip — spoke next, softly, from the side of the room. "I don't want vengeance," she said. "I want to forget it. I want my husband to go back to work, and my children to go back to school, and I want to stop being afraid every time there's a knock at the door. Can't we just — start again? As if it never happened?"
"As if it never happened," Hal repeated, bitterly. "Tell that to Elsa Acker's farm. Tell that to the men buried under the east shaft."
"Hal," Greta said again, and this time there was iron under the calm. "The woman said what she feels. She is allowed to feel it. You don't have to agree with her to let her speak."
Karl watched Greta work the room, and he understood, slowly, what she was doing. She was not arguing with anyone. She was giving the room a shape: anger here, fear there, weariness in the corner, and all of it inside the circle of chairs, where it could be looked at instead of acted on. It was the same thing she did at the post office counter, he realized: she took what people brought in, in whatever condition it arrived, and she sorted it.
When the room had quieted again, Karl stood up. He had not planned to speak, but he found himself on his feet anyway, his hat turning in his hands.
"I carried the petition to Denver," he said, and the room went very still, because everyone knew it and no one had said it aloud in a room like this before. "I carried it sewn into my coat because I was afraid Slate's men would search me on the road. And I was afraid all the way there, and I was afraid all the way back. And when the marshals finally came, I was glad, and I was also — I was also frightened, because I didn't know what came next. I still don't. But I know this: we didn't bring the marshals here so we could become Slate with different faces. We brought them here so we could stop being afraid. And if we start by running men out of town on Hal's say-so, we haven't stopped being afraid. We've just changed who we're afraid of."
He sat down, and his hands were shaking, and he put them under his thighs so no one would see.
The room was quiet for a long time. Then Ike Banner cleared his throat. "Karl's right," he said, "and Hal's right too, in his way. We need justice, and we need bread, and we need both before winter. So let's be practical. Greta said three things. Let's take them one at a time, and let's write down what we agree, so nobody can say later that we agreed to something else."
"Good," Greta said. "Then here's what I propose, and anyone may argue with it. First, the land: we open a register. Every claim, every dispute, every sale made under Slate, written down in one book, in this room, where anyone can read it. No more sales in back rooms. No more papers that only one man has seen. Second, the scrip: we don't pretend it's money, and we don't pretend the wages it stands for don't exist. We find a way to honor it — with town notes, backed by something real — and we argue about the details next week, with figures, not with fists. Third, the collaborators: any man who served Slate and wants to stay in Timberline will stand in this room, say what he did, and offer work to put it right. Not blood. Work. The town will judge the work, not the apology."
She looked around the room, and her gaze rested, briefly and without cruelty, on Deputy Kane.
"That's my proposal," she said. "Now argue with it."
They argued with it for two hours. Hal argued loudest, and longest, and Karl found himself arguing back, and Ike Banner argued about figures, and Elsa Acker, in a voice so quiet that the room had to lean in to hear her, said that all she wanted was for someone to write her farm down in a book where it could not be unwritten. And slowly, the way a river finds a channel, the room found its shape: not agreement — Timberline was too hurt for agreement — but a kind of working truce. They would open the register. They would count the scrip. They would hear the collaborators, one by one, starting with Kane, the following week.