He stood there for a while, with Poppy's hand in his, and he thought about the spring, and about the way Corinne had come to his house with dinners, and about the way she had mended his shirts, and about the way she had talked about helping Poppy, and about how, for a little while, he had let himself wonder whether a house needed a woman in it again, and whether Poppy needed a mother, and whether he was being selfish, keeping the house the way Elsie had left it, with the portrait on the wall and the blue ribbon in Poppy's hair and the braid every morning, and he thought about how he had almost said yes once, in the spring, when she had asked him the first time, and how the word had stuck in his throat, and how he had known then, even if he had not said it aloud, that the answer was no, and that it had always been no, because a woman who wanted his daughter smaller was not a woman who could be a mother to her, and because a house did not need a woman in it, it needed the truth in it, and the truth was that Elsie was still the mother of this house, and Poppy was still hers, and he was still the keeper of them both, and that was enough, and it had always been enough, and the lamps burned on around him, and the children played, and the yard was quiet, and Poppy's hand was warm in his, and he squeezed it, and she squeezed it back.
An older woman from the town, one who had known Elsie when they were girls together, came to him then, and she put her hand on his arm, and she said, "You did right, Rafe. Elsie would have said the same." And the storekeeper nodded at him from across the table, and the farmer from the north road nodded too, and no one said anything unkind about Corinne, because there was nothing unkind to say, only that she had asked, and he had answered, and the answer had been plain, and that was the end of it, and Rafe thanked the older woman, and he sat down again, and his hands were shaking a little, and he put them flat on the table until they were still.
The yard began to talk again, low and quick, and people went back to their suppers, and the lamps burned on, and the children went back to their games, and Poppy climbed onto the bench beside him, and she leaned against his arm, and she said, "Papa, are you sad?"
"No, little one," he said. "I am not sad. I am tired, and I am glad, and I am ready to go home."
"Can we go home now?" she asked.
"Yes," he said. "We can go home now."
But before they went, Poppy asked for a piece of pie, and he cut her a piece of apple pie, and she ate it sitting beside him, with her feet swinging under the bench, and she said, "Papa, will you hear my poem? I know the first part now." And he said, "Yes, little one. Say it for me." And she stood up on the bench, very straight, with her hands folded, the way her mother had taught her, and she recited the first lines of her mother's poem, her voice clear and steady in the lamplight, and the people near them stopped talking to listen, and when she finished, the older woman clapped, and the storekeeper clapped, and Poppy bowed, very proper, and she sat down again, and she said, "Mama taught me that poem, Papa. I will say the whole of it at the exhibition." And Rafe said, "You will, little one. And your mama will be proud, and I will be proud, and the whole town will see you," and she smiled, and she leaned against his arm, and he put his arm around her, and he thought that this was the way it was supposed to be: a daughter, a poem, a piece of pie, and a town listening.
He stood up, and he took her hand, and they walked out of the churchyard together, past the tables, past the lamps, past the cottonwood trees, and into the town, and the town was quiet, and the lamps were lit in the windows, and the stars were coming out, and the air was cool, and Poppy talked the whole way home, about the supper, and about the poem, and about the way the river looked in