He took the dish. The cloth was warm under his hands. He said thank you, because a man says thank you when a woman brings him supper, and he meant it, because the supper was good and the thought behind it was kind, and the kindness was real, and the realness of it was the trouble, because it was harder to be wary of a kind thing than of an unkind one, and he was wary, and he did not know why he was wary, and the not knowing was the unease from the week before, grown a little larger.
ย
Poppy came down off the fence. "Thank you, Miss Sutton," she said, because she had been taught to say thank you, and Corinne smiled at her, and the smile was warmer for the child than it had been for the father, and Rafe saw it, and he stored it away, the way a man stores a thing he does not yet understand.
ย
They ate the chicken that night, and it was good, better than his own cooking, and Poppy ate two helpings, and she said the gravy was the best gravy she had ever tasted, and Rafe agreed, because it was, and after supper he washed the dish, and he set it on the table to return in the morning, and Poppy went to bed, and he sat in the kitchen, and he looked at the portrait on the wall, and the portrait looked back at him, and Elsie's copper curls were loose around her shoulders, and the blue ribbon was in her hand, and he thought about the supper, and about the ribbon, and about the woman who had brought them both, and he thought about how a gift is never only a gift, and how a gift is always a question, and how the question was whether he would let her in, and the answer was not yet, and the not yet was the unease.
ย
The shirts came next. On Thursday, she brought them back, folded neat, the cuffs mended, the collar of one turned, the tear in the other stitched so fine you could hardly see it, and she had taken them from the basket on his porch, where he left the washing, and she had mended them without being asked, and she had brought them to the forge in the afternoon, and she had laid them on his workbench, and she had said, "A man who works iron all day should not have to mend his own shirts at night," and the saying of it was kind, and the kindness was real, and the realness of it was the trouble again.
ย
He thanked her. He folded the shirts himself, and he put them in the drawer, and that night he wore one of them to supper, and the shirt fit the way his shirts fit, and the mending held, and the holding of it was the thing he thought about, because a woman who mends a man's shirts is a woman who is thinking about his life, and a woman who is thinking about his life is a woman who wants a place in it, and a place in his life was the thing he had not offered, and the not offering of it was the thing he could not say.
ย
The town noticed. A town like Cinder Creek notices everything, the way a small room notices every sound in it, and the sound of Corinne Sutton's footsteps on the walk to the blacksmith's shop was a sound the town heard, and the hearing of it became talk, and the talk became the kind of talk a town makes when a pretty schoolteacher pays attention to a widower with a motherless child. At the general store, the women spoke of it in low voices, and the speaking of it was not unkind, and it was not kind either, and it was the way a town speaks of a thing it has decided is natural, and the naturalness of it was the thing that troubled Rafe most, because a thing that is natural is a thing that is expected, and a thing that is expected is a thing that is hard to refuse.
ย
"She would make him a fine wife," the miller's wife said one morning, when Rafe had come in for nails, and she said it in the way a woman says a thing she believes to be helpful, and Rafe nodded, because a man nods when a woman says a thing she believes to be helpful, and he did not answer, because the answering of it would have meant something, and he did not want the answering to mean anything. "And the girl needs a mother," she added, and the adding of it was the thing that stayed with him all the way back to the forge, because the girl had a mother, and the mother was in the portrait, and in the braid, and in the blue ribbon, and a mother was not a thing you replaced the way you replaced a broken hinge.