The Afternoon Three Deputies Tried to Arrest a Woman in Her Own Pool on Her Neighbor's Third False Report

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The depositions began in the last week of January, in a conference room in a court reporter's office in downtown Phoenix, with a long table, a water pitcher that sweated through every session, and the particular fluorescent patience of rooms where the truth is taken down one answer at a time. Nadia was not required to attend them, and Helen told her so, and Nadia attended anyway, sitting at the far end of the table with her hands folded, because she had decided that the men who had come through her gate were going to have to say what they had done in the same room with her, at a table, in the light, with her looking at them. It was not revenge. She examined the feeling carefully, the way she examined everything, and found it was closer to the bow at the end of a match: a formality that made the thing real.

Tom Sutter was deposed first. He came in a suit that looked borrowed from his own future, with the county's attorney beside him, and he did not look at Nadia until the video made him. He answered the preliminary questions in a voice that kept trying to be younger than he was. He confirmed his training, his assignment that day, the call as dispatched. He confirmed that his body camera had been activated at the start of the contact and had remained activated throughout, and that to his knowledge the recording was complete and unedited. Helen asked him why he was carrying his handcuffs in his hand when he entered the yard, and he said he had anticipated a detention, and Helen asked what he had based that anticipation on, and he said the call notes, and Helen asked what in the call notes indicated that the subject would need to be handcuffed, and there was a silence in which the court reporter's fingers hovered. He said: the refusing part. Helen asked him whether, at any point during the contact, Nadia Coleman had refused to identify herself. He said she had given her name when asked. Helen asked whether she had refused anything, at any point, in his presence. He looked at the table. He said: no. She asked about the laugh. She did not raise her voice to ask it; she asked it in the tone of a woman reading an item off an inventory, and she let the silence after it do the work, and Sutter, to his credit or his ruin, did not hide behind the equipment of the answer. He said he had laughed. He said he could not now reconstruct what he had found funny. He said he had thought about it a great deal since. Helen asked what he had thought about it, and the county's attorney objected, and Sutter answered anyway, quietly, that he had thought about the fact that his camera was on and hers, meaning Delgado's, was not, and that if the positions had been reversed there would be no record of the morning except the reports, and that he did not like to think about what the reports would have said. He did not apologize, because the county's attorney had plainly instructed him about apologies, and Nadia, watching him, found she did not need one from him in that room. The record was making its own apologies, in its own language, one confirmed fact at a time. When the video played, on the conference room screen, Sutter watched it the way she had watched it in Helen's office, without moving, and when the laugh came out of the speakers, clean and close, he closed his eyes for exactly the length of it.

Alex Ruiz was deposed two days later, and his deposition had the quality of his report: level, complete, and devastating in the manner of a man simply declining to leave anything out. He described arriving at the gate. He described what he had seen from the gate, and he used the word detention, and when the county's attorney invited him to reconsider the word, he declined, politely, and said it was the word for a person held by the arm and told she could not go into her own house. He described the absence of a recording light on Delgado's camera, which he had noted at the time. He described running the name. He described the dispatcher's confirmation and the reading of the July note, and Helen had him read the July note aloud, into the record, from the CAD printout, and Ruiz read it in his flat radio voice: subject identified as Nadia Coleman, homeowner at address, verified by Arizona driver license. He described obtaining the reporting party's video at the scene, at his request, for evidence. The county's attorney asked him whether he had formed an opinion about Deputy Delgado's conduct, and Ruiz said that his opinions were in his report, which is to say nowhere, and that the facts were in it too. He was asked whether he had been disciplined in any way in connection with the incident, and he said he had not, and whether he expected to be, and he said he did not know, and the answer had the ring of a man who had priced that possibility in October and paid it willingly. Nadia, at the end of the table, found herself wanting to thank him, and did not, because the room was not the place and because she understood that he had not done it for her. He had done it for the record, which was a larger thing, and which she was learning to be grateful to in the abstract, the way you are grateful to a river.

News in the same category

The Afternoon Three Deputies Tried to Arrest a Woman in Her Own Pool on Her Neighbor's Third False Report

45 Part