Nadia Osman, the general counsel, was forty-four, and had been hired by Ashcroft from a regulator, a fact the partnership had celebrated at the time as evidence of its seriousness about standards and had regretted, at intervals, ever since. She accepted the terms of reference without amendment, which surprised the managing partner, who had expected negotiation, until she explained that the terms were the first she had been given in four years that did not require amendment, because they did not contain the sentence that usually appeared in such documents at the firm, the sentence that began with the words without prejudice to the firm's confidence in. She assembled a small team. She requested, from the airline, through counsel and with the review's permission, the exhibits concerning the firm's accounts, and she received them in full, including the two closed incidents, which the airline provided because its board had decided that the passengers in those incidents had been wronged by a system, and that systems are not unwronged by confidentiality.
And she requested, from her own firm's systems, the travel records of every partner and senior associate for three years, and the minutes of the firm's staffing and resourcing committees for the same period, because she had learned at the regulator that an incident with a paper trail is a gift, and that the trail, followed politely and completely, usually leads to a room in which the same conduct was minuted, at the time, by people who did not think of themselves as witnesses.
In a file room kept at a temperature suitable for wine and for records, a compliance associate produced, in the second week, a set of staffing minutes from two years earlier, and set them on Nadia Osman's desk with the particular care of a junior person who knows exactly what she has found and exactly what it will cost her to have found it.
The staffing minutes were forty-one pages for the year, in the firm's standard format: attendance, matters arising, allocations, any other business. The compliance associate had flagged two passages with the small adhesive markers the file room used, one pink, one yellow, and Nadia Osman read the pink one first.
Two years earlier, the firm had been preparing a pitch for a client whose identity the minutes protected under a code name and whose business would have been, in the firm's internal geography, a landmark. The analyst assigned to the financial modelling was Yasmin Chowdhury, twenty-four at the time, a graduate of a university the firm recruited from heavily, whose modelling work the minutes themselves described, in an earlier meeting, as outstanding. The pink passage recorded a later meeting, at which the staffing for the client-facing team was settled. Ms Thornton is recorded as saying that Ms Chowdhury was not client-facing material. The minutes recorded no elaboration, because minutes are written by people who understand which sentences will be read later and soften the ones that will be. Ms Chowdhury was reassigned, that afternoon, to a documentation project in another department, described in the minutes as a better fit. The pitch was staffed without her. The firm won the pitch. Her subsequent appraisals, which Nadia Osman called up and read with the minutes open beside them, spoke of her technical excellence in the vocabulary firms use for people they have decided not to advance, a vocabulary Nadia had once, at the regulator, seen anatomised in a report she had helped to write: meticulous, thorough, an asset to any team, with development needs in the areas of presence and profile.
Yasmin Chowdhury was interviewed, at her own workplace, by two lawyers she had never met, about a meeting she had not attended concerning a decision she had been informed of by email in one sentence. She was twenty-six now. She answered the questions put to her with the composure of a person who has had two years to decide what she thinks, and what she thought, she said, was straightforward: she had been removed from work she had earned, in a meeting she was not in, for a reason that was not minuted, and she had drawn the conclusion available to her, which was that her face had been the reason, since her work had been praised in the same minutes that removed her from the room where the work would be seen. She asked whether the review intended to do anything with her answer besides file it, and Nadia Osman, who had decided before the interview that she would answer that question honestly if it was asked, said: "Yes. It will be a finding, if the evidence supports it, and the evidence includes the firm's own minutes. And it will go to the managing partner with a recommendation, not to a file. That is the difference between this review and the meeting."