She walked forward to the flight deck door and knocked in the pattern that meant a request, not an emergency, and Charles sat in 2A with his paperback unopened and felt, to his own surprise, not embarrassment, and not anger, but a species of professional embarrassment on behalf of an institution he had built, of the kind a man might feel hearing his own child be rude in company in a voice he did not teach it. He had not given his name. Nobody had asked it since the boarding pass. The woman beside him did not know that the airline whose staff she was threatening bore, three decades back, his signature on its founding documents, in a registry office in a city she had never visited. She knew only that an elderly man in a cardigan was in her window seat, and that the world, which had always rearranged itself around her preferences, had for once declined to.
He considered, briefly, the thing he could do. He could say who he was. It would work the way such sentences work: the cabin would rearrange itself around the fact, apologies would materialise like weather, and the woman would have her story inverted on her in a manner she would feel as humiliation, which was not an outcome Charles had ever found nourishing. And it would prove nothing except that the system bent for power, which was the very proposition under dispute. The ticket, he thought, was the argument. The ticket said the seat was his the way it would have been anyone's, and if the ticket was not enough for a man in a cardigan, then it was not enough for anyone, and no sentence of his could repair that by exception.
"Sir," Gail said, across the armrest, having composed herself into the cooler register of a person who negotiates for a living, "let me be practical. I'll make it worth your while. My firm will cover a future flight for you, in this cabin, any route. Or cash, if you prefer cash. The window matters to me. I have a routine and I have a great deal to do on this flight, and frankly, at your stage, one seat is much like another."
Charles looked at her with genuine interest. "At my stage," he repeated, "a window is one of the remaining distinctions. I chose it for the weather over the ocean, which I intend to watch. I don't say that to be difficult. I say it because it's the whole of my reason, and I find it's sufficient."
"You'll regret being difficult."
"I have been difficult at several points in my life," Charles said, "generally in rooms with lawyers in them, and I've survived the regretting. Keep your seat, Ms Thornton. It's a good seat. The airline thinks highly of it. It put you in it."
The flight deck door opened before she could decide what to do with that.
Captain Mike Donovan had been flying for Talon Air for nineteen years and had commanded for eleven of them, and he had the build and the temperament of a man who settles things by standing still until they settle. He came down the aisle with his cap under his arm and his face arranged in the expression he used for weather delays, bereavements, and all other occasions on which an aircraft full of people required the news to be exactly as bad as it was and not one degree worse. He nodded to Charles. He nodded to the cabin. He turned to Dana, who gave him the shape of it in the low, efficient voice flight attendants use within the hearing of passengers: a confirmed seat, a preference, a note, a request to escalate.
"Let me see the tickets," he said.
It was, Charles thought, the correct first sentence, and also the second correct decision of the morning, and he felt the small, specific gratitude of a man watching his own institution work at the altitude at which he had intended it to work, two levels below his notice and entirely without his help. Donovan took Gail's phone in one hand and Charles's boarding pass in the other, and he read them both with the unhurried thoroughness of a man reading a fuel slip before a long sector, which in a sense he was.
"Ms Thornton," he said at last, "your ticket is for 2B and it's in order. Mr Mwangi's ticket is for 2A and it's in order. There is no error on this aircraft today. The seats are as sold."
"There is a note on my account," Gail said. "It instructs your crew to accommodate my seating preference. I am asking for the accommodation. Your attendant has refused it. I am now asking you."