The HOA President Told Her Son, “Take His Groceries — He Owes Us” — On Audit Day, She Called Police to His Driveway

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He put his glasses back on. "I am an auditor, Darnell. I do not decide what it is. I lay out what the paper says, and what the paper does not say, and I let the board and the residents decide. But I will tell you this. If this were sloppy bookkeeping, the sloppiness would go in every direction. Some money would be missing going in, and some would be missing going out, and some of it would turn up later in the wrong place. That is what sloppy looks like. This does not look like that. This looks like somebody knew exactly what they were doing."

We made a plan before I left that day. Tom would keep going through the books, and he would put together a report, a real one, with every unclear transaction listed and every missing document named. I would keep gathering what I had: the fine notices, the bill, the notes I had taken, the things neighbors had told me. And I would talk to a lawyer, because Tom said, plain as day, "Darnell, you are a homeowner, and you have rights, and you should know what they are before the audit, not after it. You do not want to walk into that room and find out you should have brought something you did not bring."

I called Samuel Carter that same afternoon. His name had come up twice now, once from Marisol and once from a neighbor I trusted, and both times it was the same description: a lawyer who specialized in housing law, a man who knew HOA rules the way a mechanic knows an engine, and a man who did not charge people for telling them the truth. His office was in a brick building downtown, above a bakery, and when I walked in the whole place smelled like fresh bread, which made me think of Simone again, of the mornings when she was small and I would bring home a loaf still warm from the commissary bakery, and she would tear off the end and eat it standing in the kitchen in her socks.

Samuel Carter was a big man, broad-shouldered, with a gray beard and a voice like gravel in a bucket, and he had a desk covered in files that looked like they had been there for years. He shook my hand and told me to sit, and he listened. He did not interrupt. He did not take notes at first. He just listened, the way a man listens when he knows the story matters and he wants to hear all of it before he says a word. I told him about the groceries, and Cody, and Bettina standing in my driveway. I told him about the fines, the forty-five and the hundred and eighty and the seventy-five and the hundred and fifty, and the bill for three thousand six hundred forty-seven dollars and fifty-eight cents. I told him about Elena Ruiz and her two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar flower fine, and Marcus Whitfield and his three-hundred-dollar basketball hoop fine. I told him about Marisol Vega, and Tom Okafor, and the yellow tabs, and the money going out with no paper coming back.

When I finished, he leaned back in his chair and folded his hands over his stomach and looked at me for a long time.

"Darnell," he said, "let me tell you what your rights are, because they are stronger than you think, and Bettina Marsh is counting on you not knowing that."

He explained it to me the way Tom had explained the books, slow and clear, one piece at a time. A homeowner has the right to see the books. Not some of the books. All of them. A homeowner has the right to see the minutes of every board meeting, because the board works for the homeowners, not the other way around. A homeowner has the right to ask for receipts, and to ask what a charge was for, and to get an answer in writing. A homeowner cannot be fined for something the rules do not cover, and a fine cannot be invented after the fact. And most important, he said, a homeowner cannot be punished for asking questions. Asking questions is not a violation. Asking questions is the job of every homeowner in a community like this.

"She has been treating the HOA like it belongs to her," he said. "It does not. It belongs to all of you. She has been president for ten, eleven years, and somewhere along the way she started to believe that meant she did not have to answer to anyone. That is not how it works. That is never how it works."

News in the same category

The HOA President Told Her Son, “Take His Groceries — He Owes Us” — On Audit Day, She Called Police to His Driveway

45 Part