The audit did not begin with a fight. It began with a table, three chairs, and a stack of paper that was taller than any of us had expected. Tom Okafor set up in the small conference room at the back of the clubhouse on a Tuesday morning, and he worked the way a man works when he knows people are watching him and he does not care. He had a laptop, a calculator, a ruler, and a yellow legal pad. He had the HOA bank statements. He had the ledger. He had the box of receipts that Bettina had handed over, and he had the box of receipts that Marisol had kept on her own, because Marisol, as treasurer, had been keeping her own copies for years, quietly, the way a careful person does when she does not quite trust what she is signing.
I was not in the room for most of it. Samuel Carter told me to stay out of it. "Let the auditor do his job," he said. "Your job was the video. Your job was the receipts. Now let the numbers speak." So I stayed home at 14 Larkspur Lane, and I mowed my lawn, and I fixed the hinge on the back gate, and I checked my phone every twenty minutes even though I told myself I would not. Simone called me from Atlanta that morning. She was between classes. She asked me how I was holding up. I told her I was fine. She said, "Dad, you always say you're fine." I said, "And most of the time I am." She laughed a little, and then she got quiet, and she said, "Just don't let her make you into the angry one. You're not the angry one. You're the patient one. That's the whole point." I told her I would remember that.
Tom Okafor worked for three days. On the third day, he asked Marisol Vega, Harold Jensen, and Priya Nair to come in and sit with him, and he went through it line by line. Marisol told me about it afterward, sitting at my kitchen table with a cup of coffee she barely touched. She said Tom had started with the simplest question there is. He had taken the bank statements and he had taken the ledger, and he had asked whether they matched. They did not match. Not by a little. Not by a rounding error. They did not match by thousands of dollars.
There were expenses with no receipts at all. Not a lost receipt. Not a faded receipt. No receipt. There were cash transactions that had no paper trail behind them, money that had gone out in cash and come back as nothing more than a line in the ledger in Bettina's handwriting. There were payments that had never been approved by the board, payments that no one on the board remembered voting on, payments to vendors nobody could identify clearly. There were entries for HOA events that the board members did not remember happening, or that had happened on a much smaller scale than the numbers suggested. A summer picnic that the ledger said had cost one amount had, according to the people who had actually been there, cost far less. A holiday decoration order that the books said was one figure had been, in reality, a handful of lights and a wreath.
Marisol said Tom had been calm through all of it. He had not raised his voice. He had just pointed. "This line," he had said. "Where is the receipt for this line?" And Bettina had not been able to produce one. "This payment," he had said. "Who approved it?" And no one had approved it. "This cash withdrawal," he had said. "What was it for?" And the answer had been a shrug, or a vague word like "supplies," or "miscellaneous," which is the word people use when they do not want to say what the money was really for.