The HOA President Told Her Son, “Take His Groceries — He Owes Us” — On Audit Day, She Called Police to His Driveway

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The number Tom came back with was about eighteen thousand four hundred dollars unaccounted for. Not proven stolen. Not proven spent on any one thing. Unaccounted for. That was the word he used, and Samuel told me later that the word mattered, because it was the honest word. It did not accuse more than the paper could prove. It just said: this money left the account, and there is no record of where it went, and no approval for it to go, and no receipt showing what it bought. About eighteen thousand four hundred dollars. In a neighborhood the size of Meadowlark Estates, that is not a fortune. But it is not nothing, either. It is the money of two hundred families, paid in dues, month after month, year after year, by people who trusted that it would be spent on the grass and the lights and the pool and the roof of the clubhouse. And some of it, a large part of it, had simply vanished into paper that did not add up.

Harold Jensen was the one who took it the hardest, Marisol said. Harold is a quiet man, the kind of man who reads the minutes before a meeting and actually reads them, and he had sat there with his hands folded on the table and listened to Tom go through the numbers, and when Tom was done, Harold had said, "I signed some of these." He had not shouted. He had said it the way a man says something he is ashamed of. "I signed some of these," he said, "because Bettina told me they were routine. She told me the board had already discussed them. I trusted her." Priya Nair had nodded. She had said she had done the same thing. She had signed things she had not read closely enough, because the president had told her they were routine, and because in ten or eleven years of Bettina running the HOA, that was how things were done. The president brought the paper. The board signed it. Nobody asked too many questions, because asking questions felt like causing trouble, and nobody in Meadowlark Estates wanted to be the person who caused trouble.

That was the real story of the audit, I think. Not the money. The habit. Ten or eleven years is a long time for one person to run anything without anyone checking the work. Bettina had been president for a decade, and she had been a widow for seventeen years, and people in the neighborhood had felt sorry for her in the beginning, and then they had gotten used to her, and then they had gotten used to not questioning her, and by the time anyone thought to ask where the money was going, the answer was a stack of paper that did not match and a woman who had an answer for everything except the one question that mattered.

When the board called Bettina in, she came ready. She always came ready. She had her own folder. She had her own list. She sat down across from Tom Okafor and from Marisol and Harold and Priya, and she did not look nervous. She looked offended. That was her first move, and I have to give her credit for it, because it was a good move. She did not act like a woman who had been caught. She acted like a woman who had been insulted. She said she had worked for this community for ten years without pay. She said she had given her evenings and her weekends and her holidays to Meadowlark Estates, and nobody had ever thanked her properly, and now, because of one man with a camera and a grudge, she was being treated like a criminal. She said the spending was for HOA events. The picnics. The holiday parties. The flowers at the entrance. The things that made the neighborhood look like a place people wanted to live. She said the receipts were lost, or the vendors were small, or the payments had been approved verbally and nobody had written it down, because that was how a neighborhood worked, with handshakes and trust, not with lawyers and auditors.

And then she turned it around. That was her second move, and it was the one she had been using on me from the beginning. She said Darnell Hayes was causing division. She said I had come into this neighborhood and decided to make a war out of a grocery bag, and now I was tearing the community apart. She said the audit was my fault. She said the questions were my fault. She said the neighbors turning on each other was my fault. She did not say the money was missing. She said I was the problem.

News in the same category

The HOA President Told Her Son, “Take His Groceries — He Owes Us” — On Audit Day, She Called Police to His Driveway

45 Part