I thought about the mailbox. That is where it had really started, if I am honest with myself, though I did not understand it at the time. A few weeks before the grocery afternoon, I had received a fine in the mail. Forty-five dollars. The letter said I had painted my mailbox the wrong color. I stood on my porch and I looked at my mailbox, and I read the letter again, and then I read it a third time, because I could not make the two things fit together. I had painted my mailbox exactly the way the rules required. I had read the rules before I painted it. I had gone to the hardware store and I had matched the color to the sample in the rulebook, and I had painted it on a Saturday morning in two careful coats, and I had stood back and looked at it and thought it looked right. And now a letter was telling me it was the wrong color, and that I owed forty-five dollars.
Forty-five dollars is not a great deal of money. I know that. A man who has carried a stretcher through a burning building does not lose sleep over forty-five dollars. But it was not the money. It was the principle of it. I had followed the rules. I had done the thing the right way. And now I was being told I had done it the wrong way, and that I owed money for it. I went inside and I found the HOA rulebook, and I read the section on mailboxes, and I read it twice, and the rulebook said what I remembered it saying. My mailbox was the right color. The letter did not explain why it was wrong. It did not say which color it was supposed to be. It did not say who had inspected it, or when, or what they had seen. It just said wrong color, forty-five dollars, pay within thirty days.
I paid it. I paid it because I did not want a small thing to become a big thing. I paid it by bank transfer, the way I pay everything, so there would be a record. And then I did something I had not done before. I started reading the HOA paperwork properly. I took the rulebook off the shelf and I read it from the front to the back, the way I would read a field manual. I took the letters I had received over the years and I laid them out on my kitchen table, and I read them one by one, and I started to notice things. The fines were written vaguely. That is the word I keep coming back to: vaguely. They said things like "violation of community standards" and "failure to maintain property in accordance with regulations" and "non-compliance with board directives." They did not say what the violation was. They did not say which regulation. They did not say who had seen it, or when it had happened, or what the evidence was. They were letters that sounded official without saying anything at all.
And there was something else. There was no clear record of a board vote. In an HOA, a fine is not supposed to be one person's decision. The board is supposed to vote. The board is supposed to meet, and discuss, and agree, and write it down in the minutes. I looked for the minutes. I looked for the record of the meeting where the board had voted to fine me forty-five dollars for my mailbox. I could not find it. I looked for the record of the meeting where anyone had voted anything at all, and I could not find that either. There were newsletters. There were notices about the clubhouse and the playground and the spring cleanup. There were reminders about dues and about the dogwood trees. But there were no minutes. There was no record of a vote. There was only Bettina Marsh's signature at the bottom of the letters, and her word that the board had decided.
I did not say anything to anyone about it at first. I am not a man who runs to his neighbors with a complaint before he has the facts. I kept paying my dues on time. I kept my lawn cut. I kept my hedges trimmed. I kept my house tidy. I kept writing things down. And I kept thinking about that mailbox, and about that forty-five dollars, and about the way the letter had been written, as if the writer did not expect anyone to read it closely. I thought about it the way I used to think about a map before a patrol, looking for the ground that did not match the picture, looking for the place where the road on the paper was not the road on the ground.