That Sunday, Simone called, the way she always does. I was sitting at the kitchen table with a cup of coffee, and the phone rang, and her name came up on the screen, and I answered it the way I always answer it, with her name and a smile she could hear in my voice even though she could not see my face. She told me about her week. She told me about a professor who talked too fast and a roommate who played music too loud and a dining hall meal that she described, in great detail, as a crime against food. She told me she had an exam coming up and that she was ready for it. She sounded happy. She sounded like a young woman who was exactly where she was supposed to be. And I listened, and I asked her the questions a father asks, and I did not tell her about Cody Marsh standing in my driveway. I did not tell her about the groceries. I did not tell her about the mailbox fine. I thought about it. I thought about telling her, because she is nineteen and she is not a child anymore, and because she has a right to know what is happening in the house she grew up in. But I did not tell her. I did not want her to worry about me from Atlanta. I did not want her to lie awake in a dormitory room wondering whether her father was safe in his own driveway. She had an exam coming up. She had a life to live. I told her I loved her. I told her to eat properly and sleep enough. She laughed and told me I sounded like a drill sergeant. I told her I would call her on Wednesday, just to check in, and she said she would hold me to it, and then she hung up, and I sat at the kitchen table with the coffee going cold in my cup, and I thought about the fact that I had just protected my daughter from a truth about her own street, and that a father should not have to do that.
The next morning, I went out to the mailbox. I stood on my own front walk and I looked at it the way I had looked at it the day I painted it, and I thought about that Saturday morning. I remembered it clearly, because I remember the days when I do a job properly. I had gone to the hardware store on Magnolia Drive the Friday before, and I had stood in the paint aisle with the rulebook in my hand, and I had matched the color chip to the sample in the book, and I had bought the paint and a new brush and a roll of painter's tape. On Saturday morning, I had taped off the post and the numbers, and I had sanded the old paint lightly, and I had wiped the mailbox down with a damp cloth, and I had put on the first coat, and I had waited for it to dry, and I had put on the second coat, and I had stood back and looked at it and thought that it looked right. It looked like every other mailbox on Larkspur Lane. It looked like the mailboxes on Meadowlark Lane and Magnolia Drive. There was nothing wrong with it. There had never been anything wrong with it. And yet a letter had come, with Bettina Marsh's signature at the bottom, telling me it was the wrong color, and that I owed forty-five dollars.
I thought about Bettina Marsh, and about how long she had been here, and about how she had come to be the president of this HOA. Thirty-two years in the community. Ten or eleven years as president. Seventeen years a widow. Those are the facts as I know them, and I keep them the way I keep all facts, written down, without adding anything to them. But a man who has lived on a street for years learns things whether he wants to or not. He learns who waves and who does not. He learns whose lawn is cut on Saturday morning and whose is not. He learns which neighbors pay their dues on time and which ones complain about them. And I had learned, over the years, that Bettina Marsh knew everything about this neighborhood, and that she expected everyone to know that she knew it. She was the woman who organized the spring cleanup and the holiday decorations and the clubhouse schedule. She was the woman who knew whose dog had been barking and whose trash cans had been left out too long. She was the woman who came to your door with a plate of cookies when you moved in, and a copy of the rules, and a smile that told you she was watching. Some people thought she cared. Some people thought she controlled. I had never thought about it very hard, because I had never had a reason to. I kept my house tidy. I paid my dues. I waved at her when I saw her. That had been enough, until it was not.