That is why you went to the mountains, she said softly.
That is why, Elias agreed. "Not only because the law hunted me, though it did. Because guilt hunted me harder, and the mountains were the only place quiet enough to hear myself think. And then, months after Jacob died, the chaplain's letter found me there, and Jacob's words were waiting in it, and I understood that there was one promise left that I had not broken. I came down from the ridge to keep it. I repaired your roof in darkness because I did not want Rourke to know I was near. I left flour and firewood because winter was gnawing at the mountains and you had two babies and no husband. I carved the horse because Jacob asked me to watch over the children, and a child should have something made by a hand that means to protect him, not only a hand that has killed."
Eleanor looked at the carved horse, lying where it had fallen on the floorboards, its crude mane catching the morning light, and she thought of the initials beneath its belly, J.H., and of a husband who had been nineteen and foolish and then, for years, a man who repaired roofs and built root spaces and died of a fever in three days last winter. She did not yet know what to do with all of it, but she knew, with a certainty that settled like stone in her chest, that the man across the table was not the monster on the poster, and that Sheriff Rourke, smiling his eyeless smile on the mercantile steps, was a far more dangerous kind of man.
They had been talking for so long that Eleanor had almost forgotten the world outside the cabin, and that was why the sound, when it came, struck her like a hand closing around her heart. A horse neighed outside, sharp and sudden in the morning quiet, not the familiar nicker of her own mare in the barn but a strange horse, high and nervous, and then another answered it, and then the sound she had been dreading since Elias first said Rourke was watching her ranch: hoofbeats, several horses, coming up the track at a pace that was not a traveller's amble and not quite a gallop, but the steady, purposeful trot of men who know where they are going and do not expect to be turned away.
Elias was on his feet before the second beat had faded, and Eleanor saw pain cross his face as his wounded side pulled, and then saw him master it, the way he had mastered it all night, by sheer refusal to let it show. "Someone's coming," he said, and it was not a question.
How many? Eleanor whispered, though she already knew the answer would not comfort her.
More than one, Elias said, moving to the window and peering through a crack in the shutter. "Three horses, maybe four. They are keeping to the track, not cutting through the trees. That means they want to be seen coming, or they do not care if they are."
Eleanor's mind raced, and for a terrible moment it went blank, the way a mind goes blank when fear takes the words away. Then, all at once, she remembered what Jacob had built with his own hands years earlier, before the twins were born, before the fever, when he was still a young husband proving he could provide: a shallow root space beneath the pantry, dug into the earth and lined with boards, meant for potatoes and turnips through winter, with a hatch in the floor that fitted so snugly a stranger would take it for ordinary planking. She had stored apples there last autumn. She had forgotten it in the months since Jacob died, the way a widow forgets a hundred small usefulnesses of a house when grief takes up all the room.
The pantry, she said, grabbing Elias's sleeve. "There is a space beneath the pantry. Jacob built it. It is shallow, but you can fit if you lie flat. Hurry."
Elias stared at her. "Where will you go? No, where will I go if they search the pantry? They will move everything."
They will look in cupboards, Eleanor said, and she was surprised by how steady her voice sounded, now that there was something to do with her hands. "They will look behind the stove. Men like Rourke's deputies search the way men search a house they think belongs to a woman alone. They will not move a full flour barrel unless they have a reason to, and I will give them no reason. Lie flat, Elias. Breathe shallow. Do not move, whatever you hear."
She pulled him toward the pantry, and the cabin, which had seemed tiny around him all night, seemed tinier still as he ducked through the low doorway and lowered himself, with a stifled groan, to the pantry floor. Eleanor lifted the hatch, and the smell of earth and old potatoes rose up, cool and dark, and for a moment she hesitated, because she was asking a wounded giant to fold himself into a hole meant for vegetables, and the indignity of it struck her even through her fear.
Go, Elias said quietly, looking up at her from the edge of the hole. "I have slept in worse places than a root cellar, Mrs. Hayes. Worse by far."