No answer. Elias stared at the table, at the bloody cloth, at his own scarred hands, anywhere but at her face, and the silence filled the cabin like smoke.
Were you friends? Eleanor asked, because she had to sort this somehow, into boxes she understood, friend or enemy, good or bad, true or false.
No, Elias said.
Enemies? she asked, and her voice sharpened, because if he had been her husband's enemy, then everything else — the medicine, the roof, the flour, the firewood — took on a different colour, a darker one, and she needed to know which colour she had been living with all winter.
His jaw tightened, the muscle jumping beneath the skin. "Once," he said.
Eleanor stepped away from him, the cloth falling from her hands into the basin with a soft splash. "What does that mean?" she demanded. "Once enemies, and now what? Now you bring medicine to my babies and carve them toys with my dead husband's initials? What does that mean, Elias?"
Elias stared into the stove, into the orange glow behind its iron door, as if the fire could answer for him. When he spoke, his voice was lower than it had been all night, low enough that Eleanor had to lean in to hear it over the rain.
Your husband and I were prisoners together.
Eleanor nearly dropped the cloth a second time, though she was no longer holding it. The words did not fit. They were too large for the cabin, too large for the night, too large for the man she had married, who had been kind and steady and, she had believed, entirely known to her. "Jacob was never in prison," she said, and she said it with the flat certainty of a woman stating a fact about her own house, about her own floorboards, about a thing she has lived with and therefore must know.
Yes, he was, Elias said, quietly, without triumph, without cruelty, as if he were sorry to be the one saying it.
You're lying, Eleanor said, and she meant it as an accusation, but it came out as a plea, because if he was lying, then Jacob was still the man she had married, and the world was still the world she understood, and the carved horse was still only a toy.
He told you he spent three years working cattle in Montana before you married? Elias asked, and he looked at her now, directly, his tired eyes holding hers.
Her face drained. The blood left her cheeks so suddenly she felt dizzy with it. "Yes," she said. "Three years in Montana. He told me about the cattle, about the winters, about the foreman who taught him to read a brand. He told me everything about those years."
He spent eighteen months in the territorial prison at Laramie, Elias said, and each word landed separately, like stones dropped one by one into a well. "He was nineteen. Got caught stealing horses with two older men. First offence. Bad company. He paid for it."
Jacob told me everything, Eleanor said, and her voice shook now, because she was repeating a thing she had believed for years, and repeating it did not make it true again, and she could hear, in her own voice, the moment belief began to crack.
Not everything, Elias said, and he said it gently, which made it worse, because gentleness left no room to be angry at him for saying it.
Anger rose through her grief then, hot and sudden, because grief had been her companion for seven months, and anger was newer, and sharper, and easier to hold. "Why should I believe a wanted murderer over my husband?" she demanded, standing over him with her hands clenched at her sides. "Why should I take the word of a man with a poster on the mercantile steps, wanted for murder, over the word of the man I married, the man I buried on the hill, the man who never lied to me?"
You shouldn't, Elias said, simply, and he reached into his coat, slowly, with one hand, the way a man reaches for something he knows might get him shot.
Eleanor lifted the rifle. It was in her hands before she had decided to pick it up, and the barrel was steady, because her hands, for all their shaking, knew the rifle the way they knew a cooking pot or a cradle rail. Elias did not flinch from it. He moved slowly, deliberately, and he placed a folded paper on the table, and he drew his hand back, and he waited.
It was old. Oil-stained, the edges soft with handling, the folds worn thin where it had been opened and closed many times. Eleanor stared at it, afraid to touch it, because such a paper could only be a lie or a truth she did not want. She picked it up with fingers that trembled, and she unfolded it, and the handwriting stopped her breath.
It was unmistakable. Jacob's handwriting. Eleanor knew every slope of those letters, every loop, every place where his pen had pressed too hard and every place where it had lifted too soon. She had read his lists, his notes in the margins of almanacs, his short, practical letters to the seed merchant, and she knew that hand the way she knew her own. This was Jacob. This was her husband, writing to a man she had never heard of, in a hand she would know anywhere.
She opened it fully, and she read it, and the cabin fell away around her.