Elias, If you ever get free, find Eleanor. Tell her I'm sorry I was too much of a coward to tell her myself. Watch over the children if you can. And if they come looking for what's beneath the east field, burn it before Rourke finds it. Forgive me. Jacob.
Eleanor read it three times. Then a fourth, slower, searching for some crack in it, some falter in the handwriting, some sign Elias had forged it. There was none. The letter was Jacob's, and Jacob had written, in his own hand, that he had been a coward, that he had not told her something, that Elias was to watch over the children, and that something lay beneath the east field, something Rourke wanted, something Jacob wanted burned before Rourke found it.
What is beneath the east field? Eleanor asked, and her voice was raw now, stripped of anger and left with only the question.
I don't know, Elias said.
You expect me to believe that? she asked, and she slapped the paper against the table, hard enough that the lamp flame jumped. "You've been coming here for weeks. You've been watching my land. You knew Jacob. You knew about something buried beneath my ranch, and you never told me? You left flour and firewood and medicine, and all the time you knew there was something under my own field, and you never told me?"
I promised him I'd keep you alive, Elias said, and he did not raise his voice, which made Eleanor want to shout, because shouting would at least be a fair fight.
You should have told me the truth, she said.
I was trying, Elias said.
By hiding in the trees? she asked, and the words came out bitter, because hiding in the trees was exactly what he had done, all winter, while she had wondered who was leaving things on her porch and whether she was losing her mind.
By making sure you had enough food to survive winter, Elias said, and the words silenced her, because they were true, and because truth, spoken plainly by a bleeding man at her table, had a weight that argument could not lift. She had survived winter because of him. The twins had survived winter because of him. Whatever else he had hidden, he had not hidden the food, or the firewood, or the medicine, and those things had kept her children alive when the cold gnawed at the mountains and the pantry ran empty.
Elias lowered his eyes. "Jacob died before I got here," he said, and his voice, which had been steady through the wound and steady through the letter, broke a little on that sentence, as if the fact of it still hurt him in a place the bullet had not touched.
Eleanor swallowed. The anger drained out of her as suddenly as it had come, leaving her tired and hollow and strangely calm. "How did you know?" she asked.
A prison chaplain forwarded his letter, Elias said. "Took months to reach me. By the time it found me, by the time I followed it here, Jacob was already in the ground on the hill, and you were alone with two babies and a ranch that was falling down around you, and I did what I could, the only way I knew how."
Eleanor stood at the table with Jacob's letter in her hands, and she looked at Elias, at his bound side, at his scarred hands, at the leather strap across his chest with its burned word, and she thought about a husband who had been nineteen and foolish and afraid, and a husband who had been a coward about his own past, and a husband who had still, in the end, tried to protect her the only way he knew how, by sending a giant to watch over her from the trees. And she thought about the east field, and about Rourke, and about the poster, and about the lie she had told in the street, and she knew that the night was not over, and that there was one more question she had not asked, and that Elias had not yet answered it.
And the murders? she asked, and her voice was quiet now, because the question deserved quiet, and because the answer, whatever it was, would decide what happened next.
Elias looked toward the dark window, where the rain had eased to a thin patter and the first grey light was beginning to gather behind the mountains, though dawn itself had not yet come. The cabin was quieter now. Noah had settled back into sleep, his small fist curled against the blanket, and Emma breathed softly beside him, and the stove had burned down to a low, steady glow that threw long, gentle shadows across the floorboards. Eleanor had bound Elias's wound a second time, tighter and cleaner, with fresh cloth, and she had set a cup of water by his elbow, and she had sat across from him at the table with Jacob's letter folded beside her hand, and for a long while neither of them spoke, because there are nights when speaking too soon breaks something that silence, for a little while, can hold together.
Eleanor read the letter again in her mind, though her eyes were on the stove. Find Eleanor. Tell her I'm sorry I was too much of a coward to tell her myself. Watch over the children if you can. She thought about Jacob at nineteen, stealing horses with two older men, bad company, first offence, eighteen months at Laramie, and she tried to fit that boy into the man she had married, the man who had repaired roofs and built a pantry root space with his own hands and died of fever in three days last winter, holding her hand and telling her to keep the ranch. She could not fit them neatly, and that, she realised, was the point. A man could be both. A man could be a thief at nineteen and an honest husband at thirty-two, and a coward about his past and brave about his family, and the letter did not ask her to choose between those men. It asked her to forgive the first one, and to honour the second, and to understand that the same hand had written both.