The Mountain Giant’s Secret Was Buried Beneath Her Ranc

Chapter 33

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Eleanor met him at Crane's surgery, with the twins left in Ada Whitfield's care at the mercantile, because she did not want Noah and Emma to be part of what came next except as the reason for it. Cole was fifty, grey at the temples, his face lined from sun and from listening to men lie to him in many towns, and he looked at Eleanor not with pity but with attention, the way a man looks at a witness he intends to believe only after he has checked her story against itself.

Mrs. Hayes, he said. "The council's letter said you had papers, and that Sheriff Rourke had an interest in them that was not the law's interest. Show me."

Eleanor took the oilcloth packet from inside her coat lining and laid it on Crane's table, and untied the twine with hands that were steadier than she expected. Inside were two things, and she laid them out side by side as if she were laying out a meal for a guest: Jacob's copied page, in Rourke's own hand, listing dates and amounts of mining payroll money Rourke had taken, the ink faded but the figures clear; and Jacob's short confession, addressed to her, in Jacob's handwriting, saying he had spent eighteen months in the territorial prison at Laramie for stealing horses at nineteen, that he had been a coward not to tell her, and asking her to judge him by the life he had lived after, not only by the crime.

Cole read both papers slowly, twice, and then a third time, holding the ledger page up to the window light to study the handwriting. Crane, standing by, opened his locked cabinet and laid beside them Eleanor's true copy, made in her own hand, word for word, and Cole compared the copy to the originals, line by line, and nodded.

These match, he said. "And this hand on the ledger page — you say it is Rourke's?"

I have seen Rourke's hand on warrants and on the poster, Eleanor said. "And Jacob copied it faithfully, because he feared what was in it and wanted a true record of it. The silver dollar from the robbed wagon is with the tin box at my ranch, if you need it, but these papers are the proof that matters."

Cole sealed the original ledger page and Jacob's confession in his satchel, and wrote a receipt for them in his notebook, and gave Eleanor the receipt to keep. "I will take these into evidence," he said. "They will not be burned in a yard, and they will not be lost in a sheriff's office."

Then he interviewed Holt, in the same back room where Holt had confessed, with Crane sitting by as witness, and Holt told Cole everything he had told Eleanor: the search ordered for papers and not for a man, the push into the cabin despite the sleeping babies, the barn fire ordered to frighten Eleanor and made to look like a lantern accident, the watch on the road, the burning of a decoy bundle that Holt had known was not the ledger. Holt's voice shook at the end, but it did not break, and Cole wrote it all down and had Holt sign it.

Then Cole interviewed Crane, who told him, in the careful language of a doctor, that Elias Vale's wound was a through-and-through bullet wound in his right side, beneath the ribs, consistent with a man who had been shot at while standing, not with a man who had robbed a wagon and been wounded in the act. Crane showed Cole his notes from the night he had treated the wound properly after Eleanor's first cleaning, and Cole took those notes into evidence as well.

Then Cole went to the jail and spoke to Elias through the bars, and Elias told him, without pride and without relish, about the payroll wagon attack three years earlier, about the two men of Rourke's who had tried to hang him in Colorado without a trial, and about his brother Samuel, who had confessed that Rourke planned the robbery and wanted out, who had drawn on Elias, and whom Elias had been faster than. Cole listened, and asked few questions, and wrote down the answers, and when he left the jail Elias was still sitting on the cot, his shoulders bent under the low ceiling, waiting to learn whether the law that had hunted him would finally listen to him.

Cole walked then to the sheriff's office, alone, with his satchel at his side, and he opened the door without knocking. Rourke was at his desk, writing, and he looked up with his smile already in place, the smile that never reached his eyes.

Marshal Cole, Rourke said. "To what do I owe this visit?"

To a ledger page in your hand, Cole said, "to a confession by a deputy who has signed his name to it, to a doctor's notes about a wound, and to a woman who kept her husband's papers instead of burning them, as her husband asked her to."

Rourke's smile faded, slowly, the way light fades from a room when a door closes. "You are arresting a sheriff in his own office, on the word of a widow and a turncoat deputy?"

I am arresting you, Cole said, "for payroll theft from mining shipments, for framing Elias Vale for a robbery you planned, and for arson at the Hayes ranch, ordered to frighten a witness. You will come with me to the jail, and you will wait there for trial, as Elias Vale waited."

News in the same category

The Mountain Giant’s Secret Was Buried Beneath Her Ranc

45 Part