Eleanor scraped the earth away with her hands, feeling the cold soil under her nails, and uncovered the curved top of a tin box. It was rusted at the edges and dented on one side, and it had been wrapped once in oilcloth that had mostly rotted away, leaving only shreds clinging to the metal. A length of twine, black with damp, was still tied around it. Elias knelt beside her, wincing as his side pulled, and together they lifted the box out of the hole. It was heavier than Eleanor expected, as if the papers inside had absorbed the weight of all the years they had waited underground.
They did not open it in the field. Eleanor looked toward the house, toward the dark road, toward the pines where a watcher might be standing, and she shook her head.
Not here, she said. "Inside. With the door barred and the twins asleep. If Rourke's men are out there, I won't give them a lantern to follow."
Elias nodded and wrapped the box in the sack Eleanor had brought. They filled the hole back in as best they could, tamping the earth down with their boots and scattering dry grass over the fresh-turned soil, so that in the morning it would look, to a careless eye, like nothing more than a place where an animal had dug. Then they walked back across the field, the lantern's slit of light swinging between them, the box heavy against Elias's chest, and Eleanor thought, with a strange mixture of dread and relief, that whatever Jacob had buried was no longer beneath her land. It was in her hands. And whatever it said, she would have to live with the answer.
Inside the cabin, with the door barred and the lamp turned up, she set the box on the table. The twins slept on in their cradle, unaware that the ground beneath their father's field had just given up its secret. Eleanor untied the twine with fingers that trembled only a little, and Elias stood beside her, his scarred hands resting flat on the table, as if to keep himself from reaching for something that was not his to open first. She lifted the lid.
The lid came free with a soft, rusted sigh. Inside the tin box, packed tight against the damp, lay three things, and Eleanor understood at once, without anyone telling her, that each of them had been placed there by a man who knew he might never come back to explain them.
The first was a folded page, yellowed at the edges and creased from being carried in a coat pocket before it was ever buried. Eleanor unfolded it with great care, because the paper felt as if it might tear along the creases if she hurried. The handwriting on it was not Jacob's. It was larger, bolder, and slanted hard to the right, with the kind of flourish a man uses when he believes no one will ever read his accounts but himself. At the top, in that same hand, were the words: Red Creek payroll, and beneath them a list of dates and amounts, written in a clerk's neat columns.
March 1889. Payroll due, fourteen hundred dollars. Paid out, eight hundred. Short, six hundred.
June 1889. Payroll due, two thousand dollars. Paid out, thirteen hundred. Short, seven hundred.
September 1889. Payroll due, eighteen hundred dollars. Paid out, eleven hundred. Short, seven hundred.
There were more entries, smaller thefts and larger ones, running down the page like a ledger of quiet robbery. At the bottom, in the same bold hand, a single line had been added, as if the writer had been tallying his own courage: Total taken, three years, near four thousand dollars. Eleanor's hands went cold. She had seen Sheriff Rourke's handwriting before, on warrants and on notices pinned to the mercantile door, and she knew it now as surely as she knew her own name. This was Rourke's page. This was the record of a sheriff taking money from mining shipments, year after year, while the miners who were owed that money waited for pay that never came in full.
The second thing in the box was a shorter letter, in Jacob's handwriting, and Eleanor knew every slope of those letters before she read a single word. It was addressed to her, and it began without any of the formal greetings a man uses when he has time to be polite.
Eleanor, it read, if you are reading this, then I did not find the courage to tell you while I lived, and I am sorry for that in a way I cannot write plainly enough. When I was nineteen I stole horses with two older men, and I was caught, and I spent eighteen months in the territorial prison at Laramie. I told you I spent three years working cattle in Montana because I was ashamed, and because I was afraid that if you knew the worst thing I had ever done, you would not marry me. I was a coward, and I have carried that cowardice the way a man carries a stone in his pocket, always feeling its weight and never setting it down.
Eleanor stopped reading and pressed the back of her hand to her mouth. The kitchen was very quiet. The lamp burned steady. Elias did not move.
She forced herself to go on.
After prison, the letter continued, I took a short job as a freight guard, before I met you, and I carried a sealed dispatch case for Sheriff Rourke. I did not trust the man even then. I feared what was in that case, and when I had the chance, alone on a night halt, I copied one page from it before I sealed it again and returned it. That page is in this box. I buried it under the east field because I did not know what else to do with a truth that could