The man swung down from his horse with a neatness that told Sam he had done it a thousand times in front of a thousand gates. He was perhaps fifty, with iron-gray hair combed flat and eyes the color of river water in winter — pale, patient, and entirely without warmth. He extended a hand that was smooth and unmarked, a hand that had never split wood or shorn a sheep.
"Cyrus Brandt," he said. "Northern Timber Company, out of Helena. I am pleased to meet you at last, Mr. Whitaker. I knew your father, in a manner of speaking. A fine man. A practical man."
Sam did not take the hand at once. He looked at it, then at Brandt's face, and then he took it briefly, because refusing a handshake in front of his own gate would have been a smaller thing than he wanted to be.
"My father has been dead four years," Sam said. "Whatever business you had with him is finished."
"On the contrary," Brandt said, and smiled the thin smile of a man who enjoys being the bearer of a document. "Your father's business is precisely why I am here. May I come in? There is a paper I should like you to see, and it is better read at a table than on horseback."
Sam wanted to refuse. Everything in him told him to send these men back up the road and bolt the gate behind them. But a paper was a different kind of thing from a threat. A paper could be read, and read again, and answered. A man who refused to look at a paper looked afraid of it, and Sam Whitaker had never yet been afraid of anything written down.
"Come to the house," he said. "The men stay outside."
Brandt nodded as if this were exactly what he had expected, and followed Sam up the path to the low ranch house with its stone chimney and its porch of weathered pine. Inside, the kitchen smelled of yesterday's bread and woodsmoke, and the light fell in bars across the table where Sam's wife had once sat to mend harness by the window. Sam cleared the table with one sweep of his arm — a chipped mug, a folded map of the pasture, a pair of work gloves — and Brandt laid down a leather case and opened it with the care of a man handling something valuable.
He took out a document, folded in thirds, the paper yellowed at the edges but the ink still dark and legible. He laid it flat on the table and turned it so Sam could read.
"Territorial Timber Lease," Brandt said, "executed the fourteenth of June, 1879, between Ezekiel Whitaker, landholder of Antler Creek valley, and the Northern Timber Company. It grants the company the right to cut standing timber on the watershed above your ranch, from the twin pines at the head of the creek, east along the ridge to the white rock, and south to the creek itself, for a term of twenty-five years, with payment in annual installments to the landholder or his heirs."
Sam read it twice. The words were plain enough, and the language was the language of lawyers, but it was the signature at the bottom that stopped his breath.
Ezekiel Whitaker.
He knew his father's hand. He had seen it on deeds and bills of sale and letters to the county clerk all his life, and he had seen it, in his last years, grow shakier as the old man's hands grew stiff. This signature was firm and clear, the E with its long loop, the W drawn in one stroke the way his father always drew it, the tail of the final r trailing off into a short, impatient line. It looked, to Sam's eye, exactly like his father.
His throat closed. For a moment the kitchen tilted, and he had to put both hands flat on the table to steady himself. He thought of his father standing in this very kitchen, a man who had cleared this valley with an axe and a team of oxen, who had taught Sam to read a creek the way other men read books, who had died in his bed in the winter of 1882 believing his son would hold the land whole. Had he signed this? Had he, in 1879, when Sam was still a young man learning the sheep trade and the timber on the ridge was worth less than the trouble of cutting it, taken the company's money and given away the watershed?