Sam set his pen down. "Otis Grange," he said slowly, "is a man who would sell his own mother a rain barrel in a drought. If he's using her freight, it's because it's cheap, not because it's good."
"Maybe," Benny said. "But his shelves are full, and Harrison's wagon still isn't here."
That was the part Sam could not argue with, because it was also true of his own wool. Harrison's freight came in October that year, two weeks late, with one bale short and another bale water-stained from a tarp that had come loose on the pass road. Sam stood in his wool shed and looked at the stained bale, and he did the arithmetic again — eleven cents a pound, a lost bale, a stained bale, a winter's feed money gone into a river somewhere — and he felt something shift in his chest, not all at once, but the way a fence post shifts in thawing ground: slowly, and then all at once, and then it leans and does not go back.
One afternoon in August, Sam went into Otis Grange's store for salt and nails, and he found Edith Lane there, buying chalk and paper, and Otis in the middle of one of his pronouncements. "She'll fold by Christmas," Otis was saying, with the confidence of a man who has predicted the same thing so often that he has forgotten his previous predictions. "Mark me. The pass in winter will finish what the summer didn't."
Edith Lane set her basket on the counter and looked at Otis the way a schoolteacher looks at a boy who has not done his lessons. "Mr. Grange," she said, "in April you told me she would fold by July. It is August, and her wagon has not missed a Tuesday since May. Perhaps your calendar needs mending more than her wagon does."
Otis flushed a deep, mottled red. "A schoolteacher's opinion of freight —"
"Is the opinion of a customer who has received what she was promised," Edith said crisply, "which is more than this valley got from Fowler in his last two years, when his wagons came when they pleased and his excuses came always. Miss Doyle keeps a schedule. A schedule is a promise with a date on it, and she has kept every one she has made to this town."
Sam stood by the flour barrels, unnoticed, holding his salt, and he felt an odd, unwelcome sensation — something very like shame, and something very like admiration, braided together so tightly he could not pull them apart. He had dismissed Maggie Doyle in his own yard, in front of his own hired boy, with a phrase — a woman's gamble — that had sounded clever at the time and now, in the mouth of a summer's evidence, sounded merely small. He paid for his salt and left without joining the conversation, and he rode home thinking about Edith Lane's words, and about the difference between a man who keeps his habits and a man who keeps his promises, and about which of the two he had become since his wife's death had left him alone with six hundred ewes and a heart that had learned to call caution wisdom.
He did not change his mind that day, either. But he stopped saying the phrase "a woman's gamble" aloud, even to himself, because it had begun to taste like something he no longer believed, and Sam Whitaker, for all his stubbornness, had never been a man who could comfortably eat words he had stopped believing.
In September, the Anders family — small sheep people with eighty ewes and a mortgage that kept them awake — asked Maggie to haul their clip to the railhead, because Harrison's wagon had no room for a load so small and no patience for a customer so poor. Maggie took it at the same eight cents, loaded it herself, and delivered it on a Tuesday, and the Anders boy came to Sam's ranch a week later to buy salt and told Benny, within Sam's hearing, that Miss Doyle had tarped the wool double, had stopped twice on the pass road to check the ropes, and had handed over a receipt with the weight written down to the pound.
"To the pound," the Anders boy said, with the admiration of a boy who has watched grown men round numbers in their own favor all his life. "My father weighed it again at the railhead, and it matched. To the pound."