What stood there now was not a gate. It was a clearing, blackened at the edges, where the fire of 1882 had swept through the ridge. Two stumps remained, low and charred, with young firs crowding up around them. Sam dismounted and stood among the stumps, and he felt the strangeness of it settle over him like a second cold. The lease described a boundary that began at living trees. The trees had been dead four years. A lease written in 1879 could honestly name the twin pines, because in 1879 they had stood. But a company marking a boundary in 1886, starting from trees that no longer stood, would have to guess where the line began — or choose a place that suited it.
He walked on toward the white rock, following the line the lease described, and the walk unsettled him further. Twice he had to climb down into gullies where the ground had washed out since the fire. When he reached the white rock, it stood where it had always stood — a great pale boulder, taller than a man — but it stood on the far side of a deep cut where the creek had changed its course in the spring floods, and the straight line from the burned pines to the rock no longer ran along the ridge at all. It ran across a drop a man could not walk without a rope.
Sam stood at the white rock with his hand on its cold side and tried to think the way his father would have thought. His father had known this ground the way a man knows his own hands. He would never have described a boundary that a man could not walk, and if he had signed a lease in 1879, he would have told his son. He had told Sam everything else about the valley — where the springs ran in a dry year, which slopes held snow longest, where the ewes lambed best. The silence about the lease did not fit the man.
But the signature fit. That was the cruel part, and it kept him standing at the rock long after the light began to fail. A signature could be copied; he had seen clerks in Helena copy hands for practice. But a copy this good, with the loop of the E and the impatient tail of the r, would take a man who had studied the hand for years. And who, in this valley, had studied Ezekiel Whitaker's hand?
He rode home in the dusk with the question unanswered, and found Benny waiting at the barn with the flock already penned and a worried look on his young face.
"Mr. Whitaker," Benny said, "the timber men are camped up by the school road. I saw their stakes. White paint on the tops. They were hammering one in near the upper fence when I came past."
Sam felt his jaw tighten. "Did they cross onto my pasture?"
"Not that I saw, sir. But they were looking at it the way a man looks at a field he means to buy."
Sam nodded and sent Benny home to his supper, and then he went into the house and lit the lamp and read through his father's old letters, kept in a tin box on the shelf, looking for any mention of timber, or of Helena, or of a company. He found nothing. His father had written about sheep prices and a new ram bought in Bozeman and the winter of 1880, when the snow lay so deep the ewes had to be dug out of the drifts. He had written about everything except the one thing Brandt claimed he had sold.
By the time Sam folded the letters away, the lamp was burning low and the house was quiet, and he understood two things clearly. The first was that he could not settle this question alone, because the question was not only about a signature. It was about the shape of the ground, and the shape of the ground was a thing that had to be measured, not guessed at. The second was that the only person in Antler Creek who measured things for a living, and who kept the books of a man who had walked this valley in 1879, was Maggie Doyle — the woman he had refused to hire, and who had, in spite of that, carried his sheep through a blizzard on a path he had not believed existed.
He slept badly, and woke before dawn with the lease still on the table, telling himself that when Maggie came, he would listen to her properly this time, the way a man listens when the ground itself is at stake.