"It cannot be," Sam said, but his voice did not sound certain, even to himself.
Brandt watched him with the patience of a man who had watched this exact moment happen before. "I understand your surprise, Mr. Whitaker. Many sons are surprised to learn what their fathers agreed to in harder times. But the signature is genuine, and the lease was recorded with the county in Helena in the autumn of 1879. The company has honored it quietly for years, waiting until the timber on the ridge was worth the cost of cutting. That time has now come. My crews will begin marking trees next week."
Sam's hands curled into fists on the table. "The watershed feeds my creek," he said. "If you cut the ridge bare, the spring runoff will tear my lower pasture to gravel. My sheep drink from that creek. My house stands beside it. You cannot strip the head of a valley and call it business."
"We are not stripping it bare," Brandt said smoothly. "We cut selectively. We leave the young growth. The lease permits it, and the law protects it. And there is the annual payment — forty dollars a year, in arrears, which the company will settle in full, with interest, once the boundary is marked. That would buy a great deal of winter feed."
Sam stared at the paper. Forty dollars a year for seven years, unpaid, because no one had ever come to claim it. Or because no one had ever known to claim it. The thought cut two ways, and both ways hurt. If his father had signed, then his father had sold the ridge and never told his son, and the silence of it was a kind of betrayal Sam did not know how to carry. If his father had not signed, then someone had forged the name of a dead man, and the forgery was good enough to fool his own son at first glance.
He needed time. He needed air. He needed someone who was not Cyrus Brandt to look at this paper with clear eyes.
"I will not agree to anything today," Sam said. "I need to study this. I need to speak to the county."
"Of course," Brandt said, and rose, folding his hands. "Take a week. But understand, Mr. Whitaker — the lease is not a proposal. It is an existing right. My crews will mark the boundary on Monday, as the lease directs, from the twin pines to the white rock. If you obstruct them, the company will seek an order from the territorial court, and the court will not look kindly on a man who stands in the way of a recorded instrument."
He left the lease on the table, as if leaving it behind were a kindness, and walked out to his men. Sam stood in his kitchen and listened to the horses move off up the road, and then he sat down heavily in his father's chair and put his head in his hands.
He sat there a long time. The light moved across the floor. The kettle went cold on the stove. Outside, Benny brought the flock down toward the lower pasture, and the dogs barked once, far away, and were still.
Sam could not sit still with it. After an hour of staring at the lease until the letters blurred, he saddled his horse and rode up the track toward the head of the creek, because a man who cannot trust a paper can at least trust his own feet on the ground. The ride took him past the lower pasture, where the ewes grazed with their lambs close, and past the bend where the creek ran shallow over flat stones, and up into the timber where the air turned cooler and smelled of pine sap and damp earth. He rode slowly, the way his father had taught him to ride a boundary: not in a hurry, looking at everything, letting the land speak before any man spoke for it.
He stopped where the old trail forked, at the place where the twin pines were supposed to stand. He remembered them from his boyhood — two great pines, side by side, their crowns leaning together over the trail like a gate. His father had once told him that the pines marked the head of the creek the way a door marked a house.