The Rancher Who Paid $5 for an Apache Woman—And Found Love Where None Expected

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"After," Caleb said, "I didn't know what to do with the quiet. So I made more

of it. Seemed easier than — " He stopped. "Seemed easier."

"Grief is a country," Onaya said quietly. "I have lived there too."

He looked at her. She didn't elaborate, and he didn't ask. The fire popped.

Somewhere out in the dark, a mustang whinnied and another answered.

"She would have liked you," Caleb said, and was surprised to find it was

true. "She would have liked the garden. She would have — " His voice

roughened. "She would have told me to stop being an idiot."

Onaya's mouth curved. "I can do that," she said. "It is not difficult."

The laugh that came out of him surprised them both.

The trouble came on an ordinary Tuesday, which was how trouble always

came — not announced, not dramatic, just a man with a paper waiting at the

land office in San Piedra.

Caleb had ridden in for winter supplies: flour, salt, lamp oil, nails, a new

shovel to replace the one whose handle had finally split. He hitched the

wagon outside the general store and went first to the land office, because

Pete had mentioned a boundary form that wanted filing, and because a

rancher's business is never done in one trip.

The clerk was new. That was the first thing Caleb noticed. The old clerk,

67

Weeks, had held the post for eleven years and stamped papers with the

enthusiasm of a man stamping his own death warrant. This one was younger,

smoother, his shirt too clean for San Piedra, and he smiled when Caleb came

in the way a man smiles when he has been waiting.

"Mr. Haddon," the clerk said. "The H Bar H. I've been expecting you."

Caleb set his hat on the counter. "That right?"

"There's been a filing." The clerk slid a paper across the counter with one

finger, the way you'd slide a snake. "A water-rights challenge. Filed by the

Crowe Land and Cattle Company, through this office. It asserts that the creek

running through your property — the one your ranch depends on — was

never properly recorded in the territorial survey. The claim petitions for a

hearing to determine rightful use."

Caleb read the paper twice. The words stayed the same.

"That's my creek," he said. "It's run through the H Bar H since before there

was a San Piedra."

"Then the hearing should be a formality," the clerk said, still smiling. "Ten

days. The magistrate will hear both sides." He leaned forward slightly. "Of

course, without documented water rights, the ranch's valuation... well. A dry

ranch in this territory isn't worth much. Mr. Crowe has indicated he'd be

willing to discuss a purchase. Before the hearing. As a courtesy."

Caleb looked at the clerk for a long moment. Then he picked up his hat, set it

on his head, and walked out without another word. But his hands were

shaking, and he hid them by gripping the wagon's sideboard until the wood

creaked.

Delmar Crowe. The trader from the auction. The man whose face had gone

68

pale on the ridge when Taza's riders came down. Taza had warned him,

standing by the creek in the dark: the town won't love this, and Crowe won't

stop. Caleb had nodded like a man who understood. He hadn't understood.

He had thought the danger would come with guns.

It came with paper instead, which was worse, because you can't outdraw

paper.

He didn't tell Pete right away. He unloaded the supplies in silence, and Pete

watched him with the narrow eyes of a man who has known another man for

twenty years and can read his back.

"Spit it out," Pete said at supper.

Caleb told him. He told Onaya too — she had come in from the garden with

dirt on her hands and stood in the doorway listening, her face unreadable.

When he finished, she washed her hands slowly at the basin, dried them on a

cloth, and sat down.

"He wants the water," she said. "Without the water, the cattle die, the garden

dies, and you sell for whatever he offers or lose it anyway."

"That's the shape of it," Caleb said.

Pete pushed his plate away. "Territorial paperwork was always loose as a

goose. Half the ranches in this county are running on handshake records and

memory. Crowe knows that. He's betting we can't prove what everybody

knows."

"We'll fight it," Caleb said. "Ten days. We'll find every paper we have."

They spent the next days turning the ranch inside out. Pete went through the

desk drawer, the trunk in the bunkhouse, the tin box under Caleb's bed —

every deed, every receipt, every scrap with a signature. Caleb rode out to the

69

old-timers: the widow Hennessy, who had sold them seed in '61 and

remembered the creek running strong; old Finn Doyle, who had helped dig

the first irrigation ditch and could swear to the year. Some welcomed him.

Some looked at the ground and said they'd think about it, which meant no.

Onaya walked the creek herself, all three miles of it through H Bar H land,

from the spring seep at the north fence to the bend where it left the property.

She came back at dusk with her skirt damp and her eyes bright.

"The cairns are still there," she told Caleb. "Two have fallen, but the stones

are there. The blazed cottonwood stands. The split rock has not moved." She

set a smooth creek stone on the table between them, as if in evidence. "The

land remembers, even if the papers forget."

But that night he stood on the porch long after the lamp was out, the

five-dollar coin cold in his pocket, and stared at the dark line of the creek.

Without the creek, the H Bar H was a house on dry dirt. Four years he had

held this place together through grief and drought and loneliness. Now a man

with a clean shirt and a forged claim was going to take it with a signature.

Fear sat in his stomach like a stone. He was ashamed of it, which made it

heavier.

The town showed its teeth two days later, when he rode in for the hearing

preparations — to see the magistrate's clerk, to ask about procedure, to find

anyone who would stand up and say the H Bar H's creek was the H Bar H's

creek.

San Piedra had never been warm to Caleb Haddon, exactly. He was a quiet

man, a widower, a rancher who kept to himself. But it had been civil. The

saloon nodded to him. The storekeeper asked after his stock. Old friends —

men he'd ridden fence with, drunk with, buried kin with — clapped his

70

shoulder.

Now the saloon went quiet when he walked in. Not all at once, but in a

ripple, conversations dying table by table like candles going out. The

storekeeper was short with him, counting his change twice, not meeting his

eyes. And Tom Bannion — Tom, who had helped him raise the barn after the

wind took the roof in '68 — saw him across the street, hesitated, and crossed

to the other side.

Caleb stood in the dust of San Piedra's main street with his hat in his hand

and felt the town's coldness like a wind off the mountains.

The town won't love this.

One man didn't cross the street. Amos Grady, the blacksmith, came out of his

forge with his apron on and his arms black to the elbow, and walked straight

up to Caleb in front of everybody.

"Heard about the hearing," Amos said. His voice carried. "Heard Crowe's

behind it. You need a man to stand up and say your creek's your creek, I'll

stand."

Caleb felt something loosen in his throat. "Amos — "

"Don't," Amos said. "Just don't." He wiped his hands on his apron. "My wife

died in '66. I know what it's like to be the man everybody looks at sideways.

You done nothing wrong, Caleb. Somebody ought to say it out loud."

The widowed schoolteacher, Mrs. Lark, stopped him outside the general

store the next day and pressed a folded paper into his hand without a word. It

was a statement, in her neat schoolteacher's hand, that she had drawn water

from the H Bar H creek as a girl, visiting her aunt, and that the Haddons had

worked that water for as long as anyone could remember. She walked away

71

before he could thank her.

Small mercies. They kept him upright.

Onaya insisted on coming to the hearing. Caleb argued — he argued hard, on

the porch, in the yard, at the table, everywhere but the bedroom door, which

he would never have presumed to approach.

"You don't have to face that town," he said. "They'll stare. They'll — some of

News in the same category

The Rancher Who Paid $5 for an Apache Woman—And Found Love Where None Expected

20 Part