short stick in her hand, and she was pressing holes into the earth with the
kind of precision that made his own gardening look like what it was — a
clumsy imitation of something his wife had once made look easy. Beside her,
in a neat pile on a scrap of burlap, were seeds. His seeds. The ones from the
tin he kept on the kitchen shelf and had not opened since before Miriam died.
She had not stolen them. She had not taken anything he had not offered, in
21
the loose sense in which he had offered everything. But the sight of them
stopped him anyway — those little brown seeds in her open palm, catching
the morning light.
She looked up and saw him there. For a moment neither of them moved.
Then she did something she had not done before: she held up her palm so he
could see.
"They were dead," Caleb said, gesturing with his coffee cup at the garden. "I
let it go after — after she died. I kept meaning. Seeds keep, though. Dry tin,
dark shelf. Might still take."
She studied him for a long moment, her face giving away nothing, and then
she turned back to the row and pressed another hole into the soil with her
stick, dropped a seed in, and pinched the earth closed over it with her fingers.
The gesture was so practiced, so sure, that he felt a small, unwelcome
pressure behind his ribs — the feeling of watching someone do easily what
he had failed at for four years.
He stood there a moment longer, feeling large and useless with his coffee,
and then he did the only thing he could think of. He walked down the porch
steps, crossed the yard, and set his spare tin cup — the one he'd brought for
Pete out of habit — on the porch rail nearest the garden.
"You want coffee?" he called.
She looked at the cup. Then at him. Then, after a pause that seemed to weigh
something invisible, she rose, brushed the dirt from her knees, and came to
the rail.
She drank the coffee black and hot, the way Pete drank it, without flinching.
Her eyes were on the garden over the rim of the cup.
22
"Miriam's," Caleb said, because it seemed wrong to let the garden be no
one's. "My wife's. She — this was hers. The garden. She had a way with it."
Onaya lowered the cup. "She is gone."
"Four winters." He heard how flat his own voice was, the practiced flatness
of a thing said too many times to mourners. "Fever. It took her in nine days."
Onaya nodded once, the way people nod at weather they cannot change.
Then she looked at him directly, and her dark eyes were not soft, exactly, but
they were not guarded either.
"I am Onaya," she said.
Caleb blinked. "What?"
"My name." A flicker of something — impatience, amusement, he couldn't
tell — crossed her face. "You have not asked. I will tell. Onaya."
He tried it. "Oh-nay-uh."
"No." She shook her head. "Oh-NAH-yah. The middle —" she tapped her
throat — "here. Not the mouth. The throat."
"Oh-NAH-yah."
"Better." She considered him. "Again."
"Oh-NAH-yah."
This time the corner of her mouth moved. Not a smile, not yet — but the
promise of one, like the first crack in ice on the creek.
"Onaya," he said, and got it right, and the crack widened, and she smiled for
the first time since the auction block — a real smile, quick and bright and
gone before he could be sure he'd earned it, but it had happened, and he knew
23
it had happened, and the whole ranch seemed to exhale.
"Onaya," he said again, just to have the saying of it.
She took her coffee back to the garden and went to work, and Caleb went to
his chores, and the silence between them was different that day. Not the
silence of two strangers in a house, but the silence of two people who had
agreed, without discussing it, that there was a name now, and a garden, and
coffee in the morning, and that these things counted.
---
It was Onaya who found Miriam's room, though Caleb had never meant to
show it to her.
Three days after the naming, he came in from the corral at midday to wash
up and found the hallway door open — the one he kept closed out of habit,
the way you keep a hand over a scar. Onaya stood in the doorway, not
entering, just looking: at the quilt folded at the foot of the bed, at the brush
and comb laid parallel on the dresser, at the small framed tintype of a young
woman with a fierce chin and laughter in her eyes.
Caleb stopped in the hall, his wet hands dripping onto the floorboards, and
waited for the shame to come — the shame of being caught in his
foolishness, a grown man dusting a dead woman's room. It didn't come. What
came was something simpler: he was glad she had found it herself, so he
didn't have to explain.
"Miriam," Onaya said. It wasn't a question.
"Yes."
She looked at the tintype a moment longer. Then she stepped back into the
hall and closed the door herself — gently, the way you'd close a door on
24
someone sleeping — and turned to him.
"You keep it for her," she said. "Not for you."
"For you, it would be a shrine. For her, it is —" she searched for the English
— "a keeping. Like the garden. You keep what she loved because she loved
it. That is not foolishness." She paused. "My people keep the belongings of
the dead for one year. Then we give them away, so the dead can travel light
and the living can remember without holding."
"And after a year?"
"After a year, we remember with our mouths. Stories." She looked at him
steadily. "You have been keeping with your hands, Caleb Haddon. Perhaps it
is time to keep with your mouth."
He didn't know what to say to that. So he said the truest thing he had. "I'm
afraid if I start telling the stories, I'll find out she's really gone."
"She is really gone," Onaya said, not unkindly. "The stories do not make it
true. They make it bearable."
She walked past him then, toward the kitchen, leaving him standing in the
hall with water dripping from his fingers. And he stood there a long time,
looking at the closed door, and for the first time in four years the sight of it
didn't feel like a weight. It felt like a question.
---
The black mare had been in the gentling pen for six weeks, and she had not
gentled.
Caleb had bought her with three others from a mustanger passing through
San Piedra, and the other three had come around — the roan first, then the
dun, then even the nervous little bay with the white sock. But the black mare
25
watched everything with eyes like wet stones and would not be approached.
She would stand at the far rail and tremble, and if Caleb stepped into the pen
she would wheel and pace, her hooves striking sparks of dust, until he left.
Pete said she had coyote in her blood. Caleb said she had sense.
On the fourth morning after the naming — he was already counting days
from it, which told him something he wasn't ready to examine — he came
down from the barn with a rope over his shoulder and found Onaya standing
at the gentling pen fence, watching the mare.
She had been watching the horses for days, he realized. He had seen her at
the fence in the evenings and thought she was just passing time. Now he saw
it differently: she was studying them. The set of an ear. The rhythm of a tail.
The way the roan shifted his weight before he spooked.
"She will not come to you," Onaya said without turning around.
"I've noticed."
"Because you want her to." She glanced at him. "She can feel the wanting. It
makes you lean."
Caleb opened his mouth, then closed it. "I don't lean."
"You lean." She turned back to the mare. "Watch."
She climbed the fence — not over it, but up onto the top rail, balanced easy
as a girl on a log — and sat there. She did not look at the mare. She looked at
the sky. She let her legs dangle. She began, very softly, to hum — the same
low tune from the doorway, the one she had stopped when she caught him
listening.
The mare's ears swiveled.
Onaya kept humming. She swung one foot, slowly. She did not look at the
26
horse. A full minute passed. Then another. The mare took a step. Then