asked, haltingly, whether Onaya would consider telling the children about the
stone cairns and the trail markers along the creek. "They found the little piles
of stones on the school outing," Miss Aldana said, "and I didn't know what to
tell them, and I thought — I thought it would be better coming from someone
who knows." Onaya went. She stood in front of twenty-three children in a
one-room schoolhouse and told them about the markers the way her uncle
had told her — which cairn meant water, which meant a safe crossing, which
meant turn back — and the children sat with their mouths open, and
afterward a boy with a missing front tooth asked if the markers were like
secret signs, and Onaya said yes, exactly like secret signs, and the boy looked
at her like she had handed him the key to the world. On the walk home, Miss
Aldana said, very quietly, "I was afraid to ask. I thought you'd say no."
Onaya considered this. "I almost did," she admitted. "Then I thought about
the boy with the missing tooth, and how he will remember this longer than he
remembers his sums, and I came." Miss Aldana laughed, a surprised, bright
sound, and took Onaya's arm for the last half-mile, and nobody in San Piedra
thought anything of it except Mrs. Venn, who thought a great deal of it and
said so to anyone who would listen, which was fewer people every week.
There were other turnings, smaller ones. The livery man started stocking the
coffee Onaya favored without being asked. A drover passing through in
October, hearing the talk in the saloon, asked Caleb at the bar whether it was
91
true he'd stood down three armed men for an Apache woman, and when
Caleb said it was true he'd stood between them, the drover bought him a
whiskey and said, "My brother married a Comanche girl. Best thing that ever
happened to him. Town gave him hell for a year and then got over it." It
wasn't approval, exactly. It was something better: the plain recognition of
one man who'd lived a thing by another man who had.
Not everyone changed. The story would be a lie if it said they did. Two of
the men who had stood with Crowe at the auction still crossed the street
when they saw Caleb coming, and old Mrs. Venn at the boarding house
never once said Onaya's name, only "that woman," in a tone like a door
closing. Caleb learned to stop expecting the Venns of the world to come
around, and to be grateful for the Ellerys and the Cobbs, and Onaya — who
had watched the town longer and more carefully than he had — told him
once, "A town is like a herd. It doesn't turn all at once. It turns one animal at
a time, and the stubborn ones turn last or not at all, and you don't waste your
winter feeding the ones who won't be led."
As for Delmar Crowe — the town had its own way of dealing with men like
him, and it was quieter than a courtroom and more final. After the hearing
and the raid, his credit dried up the way a creek dries in August: first the feed
store stopped extending him, then the livery, then the men who had drunk
with him began finding reasons to be elsewhere when he walked in. He drank
alone at the corner table for three weeks, getting thinner and louder and then
thinner and quieter, and one gray morning in October he boarded the
stagecoach east with two carpetbags and a face like a closed fist, and nobody
waved, and the stage driver — who had opinions about men who rigged
auctions — didn't slow down for a farewell. San Piedra exhaled. The dust
settled behind the wheels. That was the whole of his ending, and it was
92
enough.
---
The feast happened in the last full week of October, when the cottonwoods
had gone gold and the air smelled of smoke and turned earth.
Taza had sent word by a young rider who arrived at dusk with dust on his
boots and formality in his posture: the people wished to come. Not to talk,
not to parley — to eat. To sit by the creek with the H Bar H and share food
the way people had done since before anyone could remember, awkward and
genuine and necessary.
Caleb and Pete spent three days preparing, and Onaya spent three days trying
not to hover, and failing, and finally giving up and hovering openly, which
made Pete laugh so hard he nearly dropped the stew pot. They set up tables
— real tables, borrowed from the Ellerys and the church — in the flat ground
by the creek, and Pete built a fire pit big enough to roast a side of beef, and
Onaya's people arrived at midmorning in a long, unhurried line: riders and
wagons and children and old women wrapped in blankets, carrying baskets
and pots and bundles, the young rider from before riding point with his chin
in the air like a herald.
What followed was the strangest and finest meal Caleb had ever sat through.
Two peoples, who had spent years learning all the reasons to fear each other,
sat on opposite sides of borrowed tables and then, gradually, not on opposite
sides at all. Pete's beef stew — thick enough to stand a spoon in, the way
Pete made it — sat next to slow-roasted venison prepared the Apache way,
and cornbread next to flatbread, and pickled beans next to roasted squash,
and the children, who had no politics and no history, simply ran between the
tables stealing food from both sides and being scolded in two languages. The
93
young rider — his name was Klosen, Caleb finally learned — taught Pete a
trick for starting a fire with flint that Pete declared witchcraft and then
practiced for an hour until he got it right, at which point Klosen nodded with
the grave satisfaction of a teacher whose student had finally stopped
embarrassing him.
And there was music. It started the way everything with Onaya started:
quietly. She was sitting beside Caleb with a cup in her hands, and the light
was going amber through the cottonwoods, and she began to hum — her
song, the old one, the one she had hummed by the fire in the first weeks
when she thought no one could hear. Only this time she didn't stop when she
realized he was listening. This time she let it rise, soft at first and then fuller,
the melody winding up through the smoke and the talk like something
climbing toward the sky. One of the old Apache women joined in. Then
another. And Caleb, who had spent a year catching fragments through a
cabin wall, sat with his hands around his cup and understood, suddenly, some
of the words — not all of them, but enough: something about water finding
its way, something about a road, something about choosing.
Taza sat across the fire from Caleb, and watched his niece sing, and watched
Caleb watch her, and said nothing for a long time. Then, when the song
ended and the talk resumed around them, the old leader leaned forward and
spoke quietly, for Caleb alone.
"She chose," Taza said. "And she chose well."
It was the closest thing to a blessing Caleb had ever received, and he carried
it like a warm stone in his chest for the rest of the night.
Later, when the fire had burned low and the children had fallen asleep on
blankets, Taza spoke again, more plainly. "When my riders first came to your
94
gate, I watched you stand in front of her with empty hands and a full heart. I
have seen men stand in front of many things — gold, land, pride. I had never
seen a man stand in front of a choice that was not his to make, and defend the
choosing itself." He poked at the coals with a stick. "My people have a
saying: the strongest fence is the one you never build. You understood that
before I told you."
Caleb didn't know what to say to that, so he said the true thing. "I was
terrified."
Taza's weathered face creased. "The brave ones always are. The others are
merely too dull to understand the danger." He stood then, joints protesting,
and clasped Caleb's shoulder once, hard, the way men did when words had
run their course — and Caleb understood that somewhere along the way,
without either of them quite deciding it, he had gained something he hadn't
had since his father died: an elder who looked at him and saw a man worth
measuring.