night the stew plate came back empty, and he stood on the porch for a while
afterward, looking at the stars, feeling something he hadn't felt in years: the
particular nervousness of a man sharing his house with someone whose good
opinion he wants.
On the fourth day he cornered Caleb by the corral.
"Town's talking," Pete said.
16
"Town talks about the weather."
"They're saying you bought yourself a wife."
Caleb's jaw tightened. "They can say it to my face or not at all."
"They're saying Crowe's telling it that way. Says you paid bride-price and
dressed it up pretty." Pete spat. "I'm just telling you what's riding the wind."
Caleb looked out at the mustangs. The dun mare was watching him, ears up.
"She's free, Pete. She stays or goes as she chooses. That's the truth and you
can carry it back to town."
Pete studied him. "You sweet on her, boy?"
"Don't," Caleb said quietly. "Don't make it that."
Pete nodded slowly, and that was the end of it, except that after that Pete
started leaving the stew pot twice a day.
On the night of the fourth day, Caleb woke to a sound he couldn't place — a
soft rhythmic whisper from the kitchen. He lay still, listening, his hand
finding the old revolver in the bedside drawer out of habit. Then he
recognized it: water. Someone was at the wash basin, moving quietly. He put
the gun back and stared at the ceiling and listened to the small sounds of
another person living in his house — the dipper, the soft step, the creak of
the bedroom door closing — and he felt, absurdly, like a guest at his own
table. In the morning the basin was clean and the dipper hung straight, and he
never mentioned it.
On the fifth morning, Caleb went to check the north fence and came back at
noon to find the garden changed.
She was in it — kneeling in the waist-high weeds, in Miriam's old rows,
pulling dead stalks with her bare hands and piling them to one side. She'd
17
cleared a patch maybe six feet square, and in the cleared earth she'd pressed
neat rows of seeds — his seed, the poke he'd bought in San Piedra, opened
and used with a precision that made his throat ache. Her hands were dark
with soil. There was dirt on her cheek. She didn't look up when his shadow
fell across the row.
Caleb stood there for a long moment. The garden had been dead for four
years. He had walked past it every day for four years, and it had been a
grave, and now there was a woman kneeling in it planting seeds in straight
lines, and it was — he didn't have a word for what it was. It felt like the first
warm day after a hard winter feels: suspicious and undeniable at once.
Miriam had laid out those rows. He could see her in it suddenly, clear as
morning — kneeling where this woman knelt, pressing seeds into the same
earth with the same care, humming some hymn under her breath. The
memory didn't hurt the way it usually did. It sat beside the hurt, quiet, like a
second person in the room. He thought about telling the woman — your rows
are straight because her rows were straight; you're planting in a dead
woman's garden — and decided against it. Some things could be said later.
Some things didn't need saying at all. The garden would tell her, in time,
whose hands had shaped it first.
He didn't interrupt. He went to the well, drew a bucket of water, set it down
at the edge of the cleared patch where she could reach it, and walked away.
Behind him, after a moment, he heard the dipper splash.
That evening she ate at the table.
She came out of the bedroom while he was dishing stew, and stood in the
kitchen doorway, and Caleb — carefully, the way you'd approach a mustang
— set a second bowl on the table and sat down at his own chair and didn't
18
look at her until she'd sat in the other one. The empty chair. Miriam's chair.
He felt the wrongness of it like a stone in his shoe and said nothing, because
what was he going to do, tell a woman with nowhere else to sit that the chair
was taken by a ghost?
They ate in silence. The stew was good — Pete's doing. The coffee was
strong. Outside, the windmill squeaked its slow circle. When she finished,
she carried both bowls to the wash basin and washed them, and dried them,
and put them away in the right places, having watched him do it exactly
once, days ago. Then she went back to her room.
"Thank you," Caleb said to the closed door, feeling foolish.
Through the door, very quietly: nothing. Then, after a pause, the softest
sound — not words, just a breath that might have been the beginning of one.
He took it.
The mustangs came next.
Caleb had been gentling them all spring — a dozen head he'd bought cheap
off a mustanger, wild as hawks, all eyes and striking hooves. The dun mare
was the furthest along; she let him touch her neck now, sometimes her ears.
The others watched from the far side of the corral like a jury.
On the eighth day Caleb came out after breakfast to find the woman standing
at the corral fence, motionless, her hands resting on the top rail. The
mustangs had drifted — not away, toward. They stood in a loose half-circle
facing her, heads up, nostrils working. The dun mare was closest, not ten feet
off, and as Caleb watched, the mare took one step forward, then another, and
lowered her head toward the woman's outstretched hand.
Caleb stopped where he was. He'd spent three months getting that mare to
19
take two steps toward him.
The woman didn't move. She just stood there, breathing slow, and the mare
breathed with her, and after a minute the mare's head dropped and her eyes
went soft, and the woman ran her hand once along the mare's neck, slow as
water.
"How'd you do that?" Caleb asked, before he could stop himself.
The woman glanced at him. For the first time — the very first time —
something crossed her face that wasn't wariness or grief. It was almost
amusement. Almost.
"Horses know," she said, "when you want something from them."
"And you don't want anything?"
"I want," she said carefully, "for her not to be afraid."
She turned back to the mare. Caleb stood there feeling like he'd been handed
something fragile and told not to drop it. He went to mend the south fence
and thought about it all morning.
That night the fire was low and he was working a strip of leather through a
cracked harness, and Pete had gone home, and the house was quiet in the
way it had been quiet for four winters — except it wasn't, quite. There was a
second breathing in it. A second person, behind a closed door, alive.
And then, from the spare room doorway — so soft he thought at first he'd
imagined it — came humming.
It was an old song, in her language, a melody that rose and fell like wind
over a ridge. It wasn't performed; it was the sound of a person alone with a
tune they loved, half-remembered, comforting themselves. Caleb's hands
went still on the harness. He stared into the fire and listened, afraid to
20
breathe, afraid the sound would stop if it knew it was heard.
It stopped anyway — a catch, a silence. She'd realized.
Caleb didn't look up. He kept his eyes on the fire, threaded the leather
through the harness, and smiled into the flames where she couldn't see it. The
tune was unfamiliar and somehow familiar at once, the way all true things
are — a song from a life he'd never lived, finding him anyway.
From the doorway, after a long moment, the humming started again —
quieter this time, but it didn't stop. And Caleb Haddon, who had built his
whole life around silence, sat very still and let the music do its work.
Dawn came up over the ridge the color of a struck match, and Caleb found
the garden already occupied.
He had been awake since first light, moving through the familiar
choreography of morning — coffee, the stove, the creak of the pump handle
— and when he stepped out onto the back porch with his tin cup steaming in
his hand, he stopped the way a man stops when he has walked into a room
and found it rearranged.
Onaya was in Miriam's garden.
She was kneeling in the far row, where the soil was darkest, and she had a