The Woman From Next Door Deliberately Damaged My Family’s Property — Then She Looked at Me and Said, “This Is Only the Beginning.”

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Lindqvist wrote in his notebook for a long time. Then he looked up, and his face had changed in the small way faces change when a visit turns into something else — when the complainant starts to look like the subject.

"Mr. Merritt," he said, "this log. How long have you been keeping it?"

"Since June. Forty-two entries."

"Forty-two," he repeated.

"We were being thorough," Dana said from behind my chair, "because we had a feeling we'd need to be."

The partner officer, who hadn't spoken, asked whether we'd be willing to make a formal statement about the intimidation — he used the word carefully, like he was testing whether it fit — and about the fence conversation we'd recorded. We said yes. We said yes to everything.

Lindqvist closed his notebook. "For what it's worth," he said, "complaints like these, filed like this — three at once, after a recorded threat against your daughter — a prosecutor will read them. And not the way the person who filed them wants."

After they left, Dana and I stood in the doorway and watched their car pull away. The street was doing its Saturday thing — sprinklers, a mower, a kid on a scooter going nowhere at top speed.

"She filed them all at once," Dana said. "That's what he said. Three at once."

"She needed the paper," I said. "The hearing's coming. She needed a stack of official-looking complaints with our name on them before a judge ever sees the file."

"And it didn't work," Dana said.

"It didn't work this time."

I went inside and added entry forty-three: police visit, complaints from G. Pritchard, answered with log, photos, footage. I typed slowly, because this one proved the log could hold weight. It had been tested, and it had held.

Grace came downstairs while I was typing. She'd heard it all from the landing; teenagers have radar for any conversation that involves their name and the word "formal." She stood in the kitchen doorway with her arms crossed, and for a second she looked seven again, small and listening for the tone of adult voices.

"It worked," she said. Not a question.

"It worked," I said.

She nodded once, and went to the fridge, and stood there looking at nothing inside it for a while, and then took an apple and went back upstairs. I watched her go. She hadn't folded. Track two had gone at her like Karen Ito said it would, and Grace Merritt, seventeen, cross-country runner, had stood in the middle of her summer and refused to become a different story.

That night I backed up the log in three places. I'd finally understood we were writing this down for people who would read it after us, and you don't get to revise a summer like that in the margins.

The Johnson County courthouse in Olathe smelled like old carpet and floor wax, and the air conditioning was set for a room twice as cold as anybody in it needed. Grace sat between Dana and me on a bench outside courtroom 3B, her hands folded in her lap, her cross-country team hoodie zipped to the chin. She had run eight miles that morning before school — she said it was the only thing that made her brain quiet down — and there was still a pale line of sweat salt at her hairline.

Our lawyer, Karen Ito, stood by the tall windows talking to a woman with a gray-streaked bob and a leather briefcase that looked like it had been through a war. "Rachel Simmons," Karen said, bringing her over. "She's the assistant DA on Dylan's case."

Simmons shook my hand and Dana's, and then Grace's, like Grace was a grown person and not seventeen. "You don't have to be perfect in there," she told Grace. "You just have to be honest. Those are different things."

"They feel like the same thing," Grace said.

"Only if you keep them together," Simmons said.

This was Dylan's preliminary hearing — a procedural date, Karen had explained twice, to decide whether there was enough evidence to send the case to trial. The judge was a man named Brenner, with a face like a folded shirt. Dylan sat at the defense table in a navy blazer that made him look like he was at a wedding he didn't want to attend. His attorney, Mark Halloran, had the kind of tan that comes from golf, not work.

Grace was called first. She walked to the witness stand with her back straight, and I watched her hands, because Dana had told me if I watched her hands I wouldn't look at the jury box. Grace stated her name. Simmons walked her through the Thursday in March: the pharmacy, the allergy medication for Dana, the turn onto the service road behind the shopping center.

"Tell the court what you saw," Simmons said.

"A truck came up behind the cyclist on the shoulder," Grace said. Her voice was thin but steady. "It drifted right. It hit him. The cyclist went off the bike into the grass." She swallowed. "The truck went past him and stopped. About half a football field ahead. The driver got out and looked back."

"Did you see the driver's face?" Simmons asked.

"Yes. He stepped out of the truck. I was close enough. It was Dylan Pritchard."

"And then?"

"He got back in and drove away."

The room was very quiet. Somebody's shoe squeaked on the tile.

On cross, Halloran stood and buttoned his jacket, like the extra movement gave his words weight. He asked about the light that afternoon, the distance, the speed Grace had been driving. He asked whether she'd ever seen Dylan's truck before that day. Whether she'd discussed the case with her parents. Whether anyone had suggested the description to her.

News in the same category

The Woman From Next Door Deliberately Damaged My Family’s Property — Then She Looked at Me and Said, “This Is Only the Beginning.”

30 Part