"No," Grace said, each time.
"You're seventeen," Halloran said, not unkindly. "That's a lot of certainty for forty yards."
"I was certain then and I'm certain now," Grace said. "I don't know what else you want me to do with it."
A couple of people in the gallery shifted in their seats. I felt Dana's hand on my forearm, squeezing.
Then Halloran changed direction. He asked whether Grace had ever had disagreements with the Pritchard family. Whether her father had had confrontations with Gwen Pritchard. Whether the Merritt household had, in fact, installed cameras aimed at the Pritchards' property.
Karen had warned us about this — the counter-history Gwen was building, dragged into a courtroom. Simmons objected twice. Judge Brenner let most of it in, his expression giving nothing away.
When Grace stepped down, Simmons stood and addressed the court. She laid out the body-shop evidence, the partial plate, the timeline. And then she said something that made me sit up straighter. She said the State had received information about a pattern of witness intimidation directed at Ms. Merritt and her family, that the conduct was under active investigation by Detective Maria Alvarez, and that the State asked the court to note that attempts to discredit a witness through manufactured disputes would be viewed with appropriate seriousness.
Brenner looked over his glasses at Halloran. "Duly noted," he said.
Dylan, in the navy blazer, did not look up. He was staring at the defense table's wood grain like it had writing on it.
Outside, in the parking garage, Grace exhaled for what seemed like the first time in two hours. "He made me sound like I rehearsed it," she said. "Like somebody wrote it down for me."
"You didn't sound that way," Dana said.
"I know how I sounded." Grace climbed into the passenger seat and shut the door. The concrete garage echoed. "I sounded like a kid who saw something."
We drove home past the shopping center, past the service road, and none of us said anything. I didn't take a single photograph that day, and I wrote nothing in the log except the date and the judge's name. Some days the documentation could wait. Some days the only thing worth recording was that she had walked in straight and walked out straight, and that the record now contained, in Simmons's even voice, the first official acknowledgment that what Gwen was doing had a name, and that somebody with a badge was writing it down.
It was the cameras that showed us how little we understood about patience.
Three weeks after the hearing, on a Tuesday night, I was at my desk doing expense reports when my phone buzzed with a motion alert from the backyard camera. I almost ignored it. The system flagged rabbits half the time, and the neighbor's cat had once given us a forty-five-minute show at two in the morning. But something made me look.
The footage was black-and-white and grainy, the way night vision makes everything look like an old war movie. A figure moved along the back fence line — the shared fence, the one whose posts I'd replaced with my father three summers ago. The figure wore a dark hooded jacket and stopped near the corner where the fence met our new garden bed, the one Dana had replanted after the lights incident. I watched the figure bend down. I watched it stay bent down for a long time, hands working at something low near the ground.
Then it stood, turned its head once toward our house, and walked away along the fence toward the Pritchards' yard.
The face was turned away from the camera. The hood shadowed what little we could see. The timestamp read 1:47 a.m.
In the morning I went out with coffee and found the damage: three of the cedar fence pickets pried loose at the bottom, the garden bed's drip line pulled out of the soil and laid in the grass like a dead snake, and one of Dana's new ceramic planters — one of the replacements — tipped over and cracked along the rim. Small things. A few hundred dollars. Nothing anyone would lose sleep over, except that it was 1:47 in the morning and somebody had walked the fence line in a hood.
"She wants us to know she's still awake," Dana said. She was standing at the kitchen window in her bathrobe, her arms crossed. "That's the whole point. She wants the house to feel unwatched. Unhomed."
Owen came downstairs while I was saving the clip to the drive. He was twelve, old enough to read a face. "Was it her?" he asked.
"The camera didn't get a face," I said.
"It was her, though," he said. It wasn't a question.
That night he asked if he could sleep with his bedroom door closed. He hadn't asked that since he was eight. I said sure. He said the latch didn't catch right and asked me to fix it, and I did, standing in the doorway with a screwdriver while he watched, and I understood that this was not about the latch.
Detective Alvarez came by the next day in an unmarked car. She watched the footage on my laptop at the kitchen table, her expression unchanged through both viewings. "It's not nothing," she said, which I noticed was not the same as saying it was something. "It's consistent with the pattern. But I can't take a hooded figure to a prosecutor and get a name on it."