"I know how evidence works," I said.
"I know you do," she said. "That's why I'm telling you straight." She closed the laptop. "You have two options here, Scott. You can keep doing exactly what you're doing — cameras, logs, no contact — or you can ask your attorney about a protective order. Given the hearing, given this, a judge would listen."
After she left, Dana and I stood at the kitchen counter, and Dana said, "File it. File it now. I don't care if she calls it harassment. I want it on paper that she is not allowed near our children."
She said it the way she says things when she has already decided and is telling me out of courtesy.
Karen Ito took my call that afternoon. "We're drafting it tonight," she said. "You have a dated pattern, a named witness, and now footage with a timestamp. We'll ask for temporary orders first — no contact, stay-away distance — and a hearing date for the full order."
That evening I walked the fence line myself, the way my father used to walk a job site, slow and looking. The drip line was coiled in the garage. The planter was glued and clamped in Dana's craft corner, drying. The pickets were nailed back. Everything fixable. That was the worst part, somehow — that none of it was big enough to explain why I stood out there in the dark feeling like the house itself was a thing that had to be defended, picket by picket, like a perimeter.
Owen's basketball was in the yard where he'd left it. I picked it up and bounced it twice against the patio. The sound was solid and ordinary. I told myself that was still the truth about this place, most of the time. Most of the time.
Later I sat down and wrote it all into the log — date, time, clip name, what the footage did and didn't show, Alvarez's visit, her exact words: "I can't take a hooded figure to a prosecutor and get a name on it." I wrote it in the flat language the log had taught me, because flat language is what survives in a courtroom. Then I closed the binder, locked the garage camera cabinet, and went upstairs to check Owen's latch myself, twice, like a man checking a door that had already been locked.
The judge granted the temporary protective order on a Thursday, in a courtroom that smelled less like carpet and more like coffee. The hearing lasted eleven minutes. Karen Ito presented the timeline — the shed, the visit at the dining table, the small incidents, the windshield note, the 1:47 a.m. footage — in a binder with tabbed dividers, and the judge asked me two questions.
"Mr. Merritt, do you believe the respondent is a threat to your family's safety?"
"She told me this was only the beginning," I said. "She wasn't vague about it."
He granted the order: no contact by Gwen with any member of our family, no coming within fifty feet of our property line for the purpose of contact, fourteen days, a full hearing to follow if she contested it. Gwen was not in the courtroom. Her attorney — a different one from Dylan's — was, and she took notes through the whole thing in a hand so small I couldn't read the page from six feet away.
The process server delivered it that evening. I watched from our porch while he knocked on the blue house's door. Tom Pritchard answered. I heard the murmur of voices, and then the door closed, and the server walked back to his car writing on a clipboard.
Within the week, the neighborhood began to know. You could feel it the way you feel humidity change — in the length of conversations at the mailbox, in who waved and who didn't. The Deavers across the street started bringing our trash bins in on Thursdays without being asked, a small diplomacy. A woman from two houses down, whose name I still don't know after seven years, brought a casserole to our porch and said, "Whatever's happening over there, it's not right, and I don't need the details." Dana cried over the casserole. "There's a casserole," she said, laughing and crying at once. "The neighborhood has taken a position and the position involves cheese."
But the order did not change everything, and Gwen knew its edges like a cat knows a fence.
The first test was the grocery store. Grace was with Dana — buying chicken, milk, the usual Saturday list — and there was Gwen in the produce aisle, close enough that Grace's shoulders went up to her ears. Not a word. Not a glance, even. Gwen picked up three grapefruits, examined each one like a jeweler, and moved on. Perfectly legal. Perfectly deniable. Grace came home and ate standing at the counter, still wearing her jacket.
The second test was stranger. A letter arrived at our house, addressed to Dana in an unfamiliar hand — round, careful letters, the kind somebody practices. It was from a "concerned friend of the family" who had "been praying" and who hoped "young Grace understands the damage she's doing to a good boy's future." No signature. The postmark was Overland Park. It had been mailed the day after the order was served.
I bagged it in a plastic sleeve, wrote the date on the masking tape, and called Alvarez.