In March I took the cameras down. All of them. The last one came off the eave with the small violence of a removed tooth, the mounting plate leaving a pale square on the cedar that would weather in by summer. I stood in the driveway holding the little white box with its dead red eye and felt, for one ridiculous second, like taking them down was the risky act — as if the cameras were what had kept us safe, and not the log, and the photographs, and Grace. I put them in the garage next to the snowblower. Dana said, "Good," and went back to the seed catalogs, and the house went on being a house, unobserved, which is the entire ambition of a house.
The small things, meanwhile, went back to being small. The mailbox stood straight. The gate latched and stayed latched. Owen's basketball rolled where basketballs roll, into the street, under cars, once into the Petersons' flower bed, and was retrieved without incident reports. Dana's solar lights staked a warm dotted line along the garden path, and when one of them winked out in April it was just a dead battery, and I replaced it, and nobody photographed anything.
I had saved the cedar. That is the thing to understand before anything else about the rebuild: when Gwen was done with the shed in June, and the police had photographed it, and Dana and I stood in the wreckage deciding what got thrown away, I carried the broken pieces of my father's bench up to the garage rafters instead of the curb. The split arm. The seat slats. The back rails with his pencil marks still on them. I told myself it was because cedar is expensive. It was November before I admitted, out loud, to no one, standing under the rafters with a coffee going cold, that I had been keeping the option of it the way you keep a phone number you can't call anymore.
We rebuilt the shed over three weekends, Owen and I, with Dana running the supply end of the operation and issuing opinions about stain. The frame first: I'd replaced the door back in the fall, but the shelves she'd ripped down were still in pieces and the window needed a proper sash this time instead of the cheap acrylic nine-years-ago me had settled for. Owen held boards. Owen learned to drill pilot holes so cedar won't split, a sentence my father said to me in this exact backyard in almost this exact tone, and which came out of my mouth without my asking it to. "Cedar's soft," I told him. "It forgives you about most things, but not a screw driven dry. It'll split along the grain and hold it against you." Owen nodded like a small colleague. "Papa wouldn't have liked the new window," he said. "Papa would have had opinions," I said. "He had opinions about everyone's windows. It was how he loved the street."
The bench took the last Saturday. The original arm — the left one, if you were sitting on it — had split through along the grain where Gwen's pry bar or boot or whatever she'd used had done its work, and up in the rafters, behind the bench pieces, were the leftover boards from the original build. Nine, ten years they'd sat there. My father had cut the bench from the shed's leftovers out of a thrift so deep it was nearly theological, and he'd kept the remaining scraps "for the repairs you don't know about yet," and my inheritance from him included, it turned out, exactly one board of the right cedar, weathered to the same silver as everything else we owned.
He was left-handed. That's the detail people forget, and it mattered here, because the arm he'd shaped had a shallow scoop worn into it where his forearm rested, a left-handed man's wear pattern. I couldn't reproduce it, so I didn't try. Grace came out to hold the bench steady while Owen and I fitted the new arm, one hand flat on the unbroken side, feeling the scoop her grandfather had made without meaning to. "He didn't carve this," she said. "Not on purpose. It's just where his arm was, every day." "That's most of the carving in this world," I said. She held still while we drilled. She's good at holding still; the year saw to that, and I'd have traded the whole skill set for her not to have needed it, but I'd be lying if I said I wasn't proud of the carpenter it had made of her — broad word, carpenter — proud of the person who could be steady on purpose.
Owen and I planed the replacement arm smooth and straight, honest new work, and screwed it home, and the bench sits slightly asymmetrical now — one sculpted arm, one plain. It looks the way a family looks after something happens to it: not restored. Continued.
Dana came out at the end of the day with coffee for the adults and cocoa for the junior carpenter, and she sat on the bench — sitting on it was the test, she said, the way you test a chair by trusting it — and she sat, and the arm held, and she nodded once, which in Dana's language is a five-minute standing ovation. "Your father would approve of the honesty," she said, meaning the plain new arm next to the worn old one. "He always said the patch should show. Shows you didn't let it rot."