I had been given the chance to speak, and I stood up with a short statement Dana and I had written at the kitchen table and cut down three times. I said that we had not wanted any of this, that we had been neighbors for seven years, that my daughter had told the truth about what she saw and that everything after had followed from one person deciding that truth was negotiable. I said the bench had been built by my father, who was dead, and that some things you can be repaid for and some you can only repair. I sat down. It took maybe ninety seconds. Dana held my hand hard enough to leave marks.
Gwen did not speak beyond what the judge required of her. On her way out, escorted by her attorney past the end of our row, she did not look at us. Tom was not there. I noticed that, and then I made myself stop noticing things about the Pritchards for a while, because Dylan's trial started in three weeks, and Grace was the first witness on the list, and everything in me needed to be pointed at that.
In the parking lot, Alvarez walked us to our car. "One down," she said. Then, because she was Alvarez and careless comfort wasn't in her, she added: "His is the harder room. But it's the same truth, and the truth's already been sworn to once. It holds up better the second time. Remember that."
The courtroom for Dylan's trial was one floor up from Gwen's, and it smelled the same — floor wax and old paper — as if the building only had one smell and it was justice, watered down. Grace wore the navy sweater Dana had bought in September, the one with the three-quarter sleeves that made her look like what she was: eighteen now, an adult by about six weeks, a senior, a runner with her hair pulled back so tight it had to hurt. She sat in the witness chair with her hands folded in her lap and did not swing her feet, which was how I knew she was more scared than she was showing.
Rachel Simmons walked her through March first. The pharmacy — Dana's allergy medication, the little white bag, the receipt Grace still had because she was our daughter and I had raised her to keep paper. The service road behind the shopping center, the empty stretch where the delivery trucks cut through. The truck. Simmons asked her to describe it, and Grace said: dark gray pickup, dust on the tailgate, the left rear tire riding the gravel line on the shoulder. "Then it went over," she said. "It hit him. The man on the bicycle."
She described the contact the way she'd described it to me a hundred times — the sound, the bicycle going sideways, Patrick going over the handlebars — and her voice went flat in exactly the way it always did at that part, which was how I knew she wasn't performing. People performing get expressive. Grace got still.
"And then what did the truck do?"
"It stopped. About forty yards ahead. The driver's door opened and he got out. He looked back down the road at us. Then he got in and drove away."
"Did you see the driver's face?"
"Yes."
"Who was he?"
"Dylan Pritchard. He's my neighbor. I've known him for seven years."
"How sure are you?"
"I'm sure."
The cross-examination was an exercise in furniture moving. Dylan's attorney, a man named Brian Kessler with the manners of a golf club president, did not raise his voice. He didn't need to. He had a plan, and the plan was Gwen's plan in a nicer suit: Grace was young, upset, filling in details; the family had been harassing the Pritchards for months — he had the complaint numbers, her mother's filings, all of Gwen's counter-history laid out like a menu. "You were terrified that day, weren't you?" he said. "Of course," Grace said. "And when you're terrified, you can be wrong about things, can't you?" "I suppose some people can." "You might have seen a young man and filled in the name Dylan, isn't that possible?" "No," Grace said. "It's not possible. I watched him get out of his truck. I know what he looks like."
He tried the complaints. "Your family installed cameras pointed at the Pritchard home, didn't you?" "We installed cameras pointed at our own property after our shed was destroyed." "You filed noise complaints against Mrs. Pritchard —" "I didn't file anything. My mother and father — my father kept a log of incidents. The police have it." "You've been quoted as saying —" He'd pull a fragment from somewhere, a school-board letter, a neighbor's recollection of a conversation. Each time, Grace answered the question instead of the implication, and each time Simmons on redirect laid one more dated, photographed, footage-backed fact on the pile until the counter-history looked like exactly what it was: paper with nothing under it.
He tried the distance. "Forty yards, Ms. Merritt. That's nearly half a football field. In glare, in motion, isn't it possible you saw a shape and your mind supplied a name?"
"I wasn't in motion," Grace said. "I was stopped, with my hazards on, standing by my open door. And he wasn't in motion either. He got out and he stood there. People keep saying forty yards like it's far. It's the distance from our driveway to the Pritchards'. I have watched Dylan cross it a thousand times. I know his walk. I know the truck. He looked right at me, Mr. Kessler. He saw me see him. That's why he left."