Leo thought about Corey, in another cell or another room, crying again, probably, and blaming himself for coming along. Corey had not been Leo's first choice for tonight. He had been the only choice. Leo had called three other people before Corey, and all three had said no, or not answered, or laughed at him. Corey had said yes because Corey always said yes to Leo, because cousins were supposed to, because Corey had spent years trying to look tougher than he was and saying yes to Leo was the toughest thing he knew how to do.
Leo thought about Mike Callahan, sitting across the table, not moving, not shouting, saying that line in a whisper that had somehow been louder than any shout. Point that thing at me one more time, and the last sound you'll ever hear is the coffee cup I set down on this table. Leo had not understood the line when he heard it. He understood it now, sitting on a bench in a cell, with his hands empty: the last sound had not been a gunshot. It had been a cup. It had been a choice. Mike had chosen stillness, and Leo, without quite meaning to, had chosen it too, when his arms gave out and the gun fell.
He did not sleep. He sat, and he waited, and the fluorescent lights hummed, and somewhere down the hall a phone rang and rang and stopped.
Corey Baxter cried in the interview room, and then he apologized for crying, and then he cried again because he was embarrassed about apologizing. The deputy who sat across from him — a woman with a kind face and a notebook — did not rush him. She gave him water in a paper cup, and tissues, and time. Corey drank the water in small, careful sips, as if he were afraid of spilling it and making things worse.
"I didn't want to do it," Corey said, when he could get the words out in order. "I swear, I didn't want to. Leo's my cousin. He said we just had to go in and scare them a little, and they'd give us the money, and nobody would get hurt. He said Richie would — he said if we didn't, Richie would hurt him. I believed him. I still believe him, I think. Richie's not a guy you say no to."
The deputy wrote that down. "Richie who?" she asked.
"Richie Colton," Corey said. "He's got a used-car lot near Fresno. He lent Leo money. For Leo's mom. It was supposed to be eight hundred, but then it kept getting bigger, and Leo couldn't pay it, and Richie gave him the shotgun and said —" Corey stopped, his throat closing. "He said the diner would have the money. He said Friday nights were good. I don't know if that's true. I don't think Leo knew if it was true either. We just — we went because we didn't know what else to do."
Corey told the story in pieces, doubling back, correcting himself, starting over when he got the order wrong. He told them about the 2003 Dodge Neon, about driving down from Fresno, about sitting in the car outside the Desert Rose and sweating through his t-shirt and trying not to throw up. He told them about the rusty .38, which had belonged to someone Corey would not name at first and then named, haltingly, because it did not matter anymore. He told them about walking in with the stiff, self-conscious strut he had practiced in his bedroom mirror, trying to look like the men in movies who did this kind of thing without flinching. He had flinched. He had flinched the whole time.
"When the man at the table talked," Corey said, "I thought — I thought he was going to get himself killed. I thought Leo was going to shoot him. And then Leo didn't. And then I just — I couldn't hold it anymore. I couldn't hold the gun, I couldn't hold the crying, I couldn't hold any of it. I'm sorry. I'm so sorry to those people. To the waitress. To the old man. To the couple. To Mr. Callahan. I'm sorry."
The deputy closed her notebook, gently. "Corey," she said, "you're going to be able to tell them that yourself, in time. Right now, I need you to tell me everything you remember about Richie Colton, as clearly as you can. Dates, amounts, what he said, where he said it. Can you do that?"
Corey nodded, wiping his face with a tissue that came apart in his hands. "I'll try," he said. "I want to try. I don't want to be the guy who did this anymore."
Outside the interview room, Sergeant Hargrove stood in the hallway with a cup of station coffee gone cold in his hand, listening to the murmur through the door, and thinking about how young twenty-three looked when it was sitting in a chair crying. He had seen a lot of young men come through this station. Most of them got harder as the night went on. This one was getting softer, and Hargrove was not sure whether that was a good sign or a bad one. He decided, for now, to take it as a good sign: a man who could cry about what he had done was a man who might not do it again.