"I want to be careful," he told Desai, and to the associate taking notes. "I am not a complainant. Nothing happened to me. I sat in the right seat and I flew the airplane and I went home. I want that understood before I say the rest, because the rest is about a pattern, and a pattern you observe from the right seat is a different thing from a thing that happened to you, and I don't want it weighted wrong."
"Tell us the pattern as you observed it," Desai said.
He opened the notebook to the back. "Three times in the last year, flying with Captain Moser, I have watched him challenge a passenger's right to a seat the passenger was ticketed for. The first was in March, in Dallas, a woman in the premium cabin traveling with a child. He questioned whether her upgrade was legitimate, at the door, in front of the cabin, and had the agent re-verify her record before he would close the door. Her record was exactly as issued. He said the system makes errors and somebody has to catch them. The second was in June, in St. Louis. A man in a wheelchair whose seat assignment had been changed by the system, and the captain questioned whether the passenger had requested the assistance he was receiving, as if assistance were a benefit a person might steal. The station sorted it. The passenger cried, quietly, in row one, and the cabin pretended to be reading."
"And the third?" Desai asked.
"The third was Flight 207," Pappas said. "You have that one." He turned the notebook around so that the investigators could see the list: dates, flight numbers, city pairs, in a pilot's compact hand, each entry no longer than a line, the last of them still in the morning's ink. "I started keeping it after the second one. I don't know why I didn't report it. That is not true. I do know why. I am a first officer. Captains write the letters that decide whether a first officer upgrades, and a reputation for writing reports about captains is a reputation that follows you into every crew lounge in the system. I told myself the March one was a paperwork question and the June one was a bad day. I wrote them down anyway. I think I wrote them down so that if I ever had to decide whether I was the kind of man who had seen something, the answer would be in my own handwriting. Then on 207 I stood in the cockpit door with a departure estimate in my hand and watched him do it to a man who turned out to own the airline, and I understood that my list was not about whether I was that kind of man. It was about how many people he was going to do it to while I was deciding."
Desai let the silence do its work. "What did you observe about the selection?" she asked. "In the three instances."
Pappas looked at his list for a moment, a man reading his own evidence with care. "The woman in Dallas was Black. The man in St. Louis was brown and in a wheelchair, and I cannot separate those two facts and I am not going to pretend I can. The man on 207 you know. I have flown with Captain Moser perhaps forty times in three years, and I have never once seen him challenge a passenger who looked the way he expects first class to look, and I have seen him wave through irregularities that were actually irregular: an expired companion pass he did not want to delay for, a lap child with no documentation in February that he laughed about. The pattern is not that he checks. Checking is the job. The pattern is who earns the checking."
He slid the notebook across the table. "Copies," he said. "I made copies before I came. The original stays with me. A purser on 207 taught the whole crew something about paper this month, whether she knows it or not. Everybody in this company is keeping copies now."