His own statement to the investigators had been taken in the second week, under the same protocol as every other witness, in the same hotel conference room, with the same warning that notes would be taken and attributed, and he had insisted on one thing only, which was that it not be taken at headquarters and not be taken first. "Interview me in the order the evidence puts me," he had told Desai. "Which is as a passenger. Seat 1A. That is the order I was in the cabin, and I want the file to keep it." She had agreed without comment, and he had given his account across two hours with the flat completeness of a man reading a load sheet: the demand, the documents, the order, the purser's refusal, his requests, the notebook. When she asked him the question the file required, whether at any point he had identified himself to the captain as the chairman of the controlling trust, he said no, and when she asked whether he had considered it, the transcript recorded a pause of some length.
"I considered it in the way you consider a door you have decided not to open," he said at last. "Everything in my history with doors like that one said: say the word, end the moment, be the exception. And everything I believe about the company I own said: the exception is the disease. If I stand up in that cabin and say who I am, then the lesson the morning teaches every person in it is that a passenger needs to own the airline to keep his seat. I would rather the lesson be the other one, even if it takes longer and costs the company a delay and me a morning. Especially then. A lesson that costs nothing teaches nothing; I learned that on loading docks. Also, I will say this for the record, because Ruth told me to be complete and she is right more often than the record will ever know: part of me wanted to see what the company would do when it did not know I was watching. That is an owner's vanity, Ms. Desai. It is the truck-riding habit with the romance stripped off. I have put it in my own statement at home, to my wife, in stronger language. For yours: I did not announce myself, I would not do it differently, and I am aware that the choice was available to me in a way it is available to no other passenger we carry, and that awareness is part of what this investigation is for."
Desai had then asked him about the dashboard, and the transcript of that portion was short. He described receiving the quarterly reports across two years, the zeros, the feeling in the spring, the audit commissioned on the feeling. He described the evening in the Boston hotel. And he said, "I want the record to show that the first complaint I ever asked this company to produce for me was my own, from seat 1A, and that I am ashamed of the sentence I just said. A system in which the owner has to be personally insulted in his own cabin to discover that complaints vanish is a system that has failed in its design, and the design failure is mine as much as any man's, because I am the one who kept accepting the summary. I have run warehouses where I would have fired a manager for handing me a count he had not walked. I accepted a count about human dignity from people I had not watched count. Put that in the findings wherever findings put such things. I will sign it."
Captain Gerry Moser gave his interview in the sixth week, in the same hotel conference room, with his union representative beside him and a union lawyer beside the representative, and he was, the investigators recorded, composed, courteous, and entirely unpersuaded.
He had prepared. That was evident in the first minutes and remained evident: he had the manner of a man who had reviewed his own file, such as he understood it to be, and had found it in order. Twenty-six years in aviation. Fourteen at Northwind. No accidents, no incidents, a check-ride record that any chief pilot would sign, a training file full of the small commendations that accumulate to careful men. He described the morning of Flight 207 as he had experienced it, and the experience, in his telling, had a shape that he clearly believed any reasonable professional would recognize: a first-class cabin, a passenger whose documents had been validated by a scanner but whose presence had raised, in the captain's judgment, a cluster of small inconsistencies, the kind that experience teaches a captain to resolve before departure rather than at altitude. He could not, when Desai asked him to enumerate the inconsistencies, produce one that survived the asking. The suit was not the usual suit. The passenger had boarded with a coffee from the terminal. The passenger had not opened a laptop. He had, Moser said, an air of waiting that Moser had learned to associate with persons traveling on documents they had not come by honestly.